Paul Bascobart, the president of Bloomberg BusinessWeek, started off the second day of the 2010 Media Summit, Thursday, March 11, by indicating that today’s sessions were going to be more print-oriented, as opposed to yesterday, which had been more television and video-centric. He introduced James Ellis (henceforth to be referred to as E), the assistant managing editor of Bloomberg BusinessWeek, who was going to be interviewing Arthur O. Sulzberger, Jr. (referred to below as A), Chairman, The New York Times Company & Publisher, The New York Times, and Janet L. Robinson (noted below as J), President and Chief Executive Officer, The New York Times Company.
E: The New York Times is engaged in looking at new methods of delivery and involved in a search for a new business model. Among the media properties of the New York Times Company, the focus of the morning’s discussion would be on the challenges faced by the New York Times (NYT) - America’s premier media brand. In its160-year history, it has shown a tremendous ability to change, creating hope that it can do so again.
What does the NYT brand mean and how much of an advantage does it provide in dealing with the necessary changes?
A: He doesn’t believe that everything is changing, i.e., that up is down and vice versa. The challenge is converting what the NYT does so well to a whole new way of operating. This challenge goes beyond adapting to the new formats.
Instead, the real challenge is that of keeping the brand promise for all of its brands as they accelerate through the digital transition. Brand is critical as long as you don’t allow it to handcuff you. It’s not how people get info, but the quality of the news & info, and the integration of reporting into the social web.
E: The NYT brand is so closely associated with print – does that handcuff the brand?
J: It is an advantage to have the strength of the brand name. We can continue to endear ourselves to those who are loyal to the print product while developing loyalty with new users in the new formats.
The key to the NYT’s brand differentiation is its strong commitment to quality. People understand and applaud what they have done as we transition into a web format.
E: When people think about older brands on the web, they get tripped up on the distinction between journalism and content. Is it a more difficult challenge for a brand based on quality journalism to move into the content arena?
J: If we looked at the transition as simply to digital, as with a generic “newspaper.com,” then it would be a problem. The entire experience has to be extremely rich; it’s not just about transferring articles to a web format. The NYT invested early in the web, as far back as 1994-95; we embraced it as an opportunity, not a threat. There is no denying that it’s part of our future. Thanks to those efforts, we became the #1 newspaper website and the #5 overall news & info site early.
A: We recognized early that there was a lot that we didn’t know. J spearheaded the creation of a research & development department to provide a little more direction for the future.
E: When media companies refer to themselves as being platform-agnostic, it raises the ire of journalists.
A: That approach is positive because we can’t define ourselves by method of distribution. Otherwise, we would still be using pigeons. The New York Herald foresaw the death of newspapers in 1850 due to the advent of the telegraph.
We are platform-agnostic because we care about journalism, which creates a valued audience, which we sell to advertisers.
The iPad and the Kindle are critical parts of our future
E: How is the condition of the economy changing the need for the transition – is it making it faster?
J: The need for change is faster due to the economy, consumer trending and changing habits. As a result, the advertiser has become very careful in spending money. Lots of dollars were held back recently. More recently, people are recognizing an opportunity to capture market share, so there is an increased interest in getting their message out and choosing methods that work for them.
E: Is there a long-term decline in trend for ad spending?
J: There has to be a commercial marketplace. People have to get their messages out in order to sell goods and services. The speed of the ad recovery, however, is still to be determined, although we are starting to see people have strong interest in gaining share.
The history of recessions is that people who come out early can steal market share.
E: Historically, they have been investing during tough periods. Was this recession different?
J: We have continued to invest. We have done some cost restructuring also. We have invested in journalism, technology and our digital future.
The cost cutting was in the newspaper distribution and production side of the business. We needed to be a more productive and efficient operation. One could ask: Why not do that earlier? A crisis should not be wasted.
We also looked at our portfolio carefully and divested non-core properties.
E: Managers presumably understand cost cutting, but how about journalists? How do you communicate that message to the editorial side?
A: It wasn’t hard to communicate that because Bill Keller and the newsroom saw the painful work being done on the business side where the numbers shrank dramatically. Also, we are being selective in hiring but bringing in new people on the editorial side.
J: Newsrooms understand that there has to be a constant re-evaluation of resources. At the same time, quality journalism can’t be created without a healthy business operation.
Over all, the understanding between the editorial and the business sides is the best it’s ever been.
E: Did you think that digital would change the business this much and this quickly?
A: Everyone recognized the opportunity – get news and information out regardless of the location of the printing presses – we can now serve people at enormous distances.
The speed of the challenge, however, has moved faster than expected.
We are now moving into the secondary and tertiary phases – the social media phase. We are becoming parts of conversations happening all around us, not through us. This will require us to have a new mindset.
E: Is this a net plus?
A: It’s a net plus if you get it right
What are the best ways to keep a quality audience growing and keep them engaged with what we do? If it requires being on Facebook, then we have to be on Facebook.
E: The media is used to one-way conversations. The ability to have two-way conversations is exciting, but how do we preserve what is worthwhile to us and our advertisers?
A: The challenge is what to do about a two-way conversation that doesn’t include you. How do you make your information part of the conversation?
E: Let’s look at the old-media, traditional part of the business. Newspapers are challenged. Advertisers are looking at how they want to play the recovery. Will the end of the year look better for newspapers in general?
J: Everyone in our newspaper business has embraced the internet as a wonderful opportunity [Note: seems a little late.]
E: Who is your guide for managing through a bad economy?
J: Industries that restructured their traditional businesses in order to invest in new technology. Our peer group is still committed to quality – Washington Post, Financial Times, Conde Nast.
New companies like Facebook and Twitter are good at reading consumer trends.
E: Do we need to stop thinking about media so much as being ad-supported?
J: Yes. Our circulation revenue base has grown to 40% of total revenue.
Diversified revenue streams are good for the company in the long term. We put a lot of deliberation to our decision to go into a pay model for the website in 2011. We looked at lots of pay models in terms of their impact on our audience and our advertisers, and the willingness of consumers to pay for content.
We settled on a metered model – we think that we have found a balance for the appropriate amount of free and paid content. We feel there is an opportunity to gain a good deal of revenue from this pay model.
It takes this period of time to get everything right, so we had to announce this way before our launch date.
E: Lessons from Times Select?
A: People were willing to pay for content. Later, since digital advertising was skyrocketing, we took down the pay wall in order to take advantage of ad revenue opportunities.
The new pay wall is due to recent changes – it shows the power of testing and adapting. Will a pay wall be the right thing 10 years from now? Don’t know.
E: Murdoch and others are trying to deal with content aggregators. How do you feel about aggregators?
A: We can’t put all content aggregators in the same box. There’s a contrast between fair use and theft. Google is a powerful part of our ecosystem and we work with them well. Other sites lift content and don’t even link back to us – that’s theft.
E: How about new devices – are they trying to figure out the ad model so that ads work as well as on existing formats?
J: It’s early to predict the ad experience on the new devices. Ads will have an important role – it may be similar to web format or it may be comparatively different.
Media companies are working on making the content experience enjoyable – there is an opportunity for marketers to do the same for ad experiences. Advertisers have taken advantage of video and larger ad formats online.
The NYT R&D lab has been a useful place to bring advertising agencies and clients to show them future advertising opportunities. We had created the lab in order to be in the forefront of technology changes.
Furthermore, the NYT was the first company to integrate our print and digital efforts in both content and advertising.
E: Carlos Slim has a 6.5% ownership of the NYT Company. What about others who want to participate in ownership in this family-controlled company?
A: People who want to participate with the NYT can be shareholders [albeit of non-voting stock]. We are delighted to have Carlos as a major investor in the NYT Company. He believes in our mission and the quality of what we do [Note: sounds good, but who really believes this?]
E: Are you recruiting long-term investors?
A: Investors who don’t share our vision sell their shares. The Company is not going to be sold or split apart.
Audience Q: What is the most challenging aspect in serving a traditional base of customers and advertisers who are not as digitally connected?
J: Part of the rationale of the R&D lab is to show the effectiveness of the web to advertisers. Some advertisers very advanced, others are coming along. We also show advertisers what others are doing in their own space via the R&D lab.
The lab is a differentiating factor as is our journalism.
A: Print is not going away. We recently opened another print site – we have more print sites than we could have imagined.
The number of print subscribers who have been with us more than 2 years – who are generally considered lifetime customers – increased in the last several years from 650,000 up to 820,000.
Q: If the paid model doesn’t work, what are your options?
J: We would look at alternative models to adjust or diversify our revenue streams or create new revenue streams. For now, the metered model seemed best from a research perspective.
Q: How can we get ourselves and our clients to see the lab?
J: Call her.
Q: You are accustomed to a direct relationship with your customers – what happens in a device world where there are intermediaries between you and your customer?
A: The relationship with our customers is critical to our success – we will maintain that relationship.
J: A critical part of the analysis to understand how consumers use the paper and digital products – what’s the consumer behavior?
Q: It’s important for consumers to pay for content. But it is hard to change consumer behavior. How can you change the consumer propensity to get them to pay?
A: Focus on the ease of the consumer experience. It is not necessarily as hard as assumed to change consumer behavior. We expect that our core loyal audience will move over to the pay model.
J: We should give more credit to the consumer with regard to their judgment regarding quality. Consumers understand what is and is not quality. Also, consumers understand that quality journalism is expensive and has to be paid for. We will continue to invest in the experience – we will improve our product and add more goods and services.
Q: How much of your revenue is from digital?
J: 14% and expected to increase. A large group of advertisers buy both print and online, and that is why we integrated the newsrooms, sales and marketing.
The changing media landscape - what does it mean to us as content providers, consumers of media, and purchasers of goods and services of which we are inundated by marketers and their messages. You can also follow me on Twitter: http://twitter.com/victorllee
Sunday, March 14, 2010
Notes from 2010 Media Summit: Interview with Jonathan Klein, President, CNN/US
The 2010 Media Summit opened on March 10, 2010 at the McGraw-Hill Building in Manhattan. My notes are below, with the caveats that they are my best rendition of the discussion, with no claim to accuracy; much of the discussion has been paraphrased, rather than being a direct quote of the participants; and I bring my own viewpoint and perspective to this discussion, which influences my perception of the discussion.
Introductory remarks were from Paul Bascobart, the president of Bloomberg BusinessWeek. He started out by saying that this was a particularly interesting year to review business models [Note: aren’t they all lately, and for the foreseeable future as well?] and predicted that the Summit’s sessions would include some “old-fashioned Italian fistfights.” He pointed out, as everyone in the audience presumably knew, that last year’s summit had been held in the midst of the financial crisis. The stock and ad markets were down, and iconic media brands were going out of business.
It was now three months since the acquisition of BusinessWeek magazine by Bloomberg. He proclaimed that they are on the cusp of the relaunch of an exciting new magazine. He said that it was going against the trends of the magazine business – there would be more stories with increased frequency of publication on thicker paper, an integrated newsroom with 2300 reporters, and on April 23, a new.businesweek.com.
He then introduced Josh Tyrangiel, who had joined Bloomberg BusinessWeek as Editor in November from Time, where he had been deputy managing editor at Time magazine and managing editor at Time.com. Josh (T) was to interview Jonathan Klein (K), the president of CNN/US since 2005 as the first event of the Summit.
T offered up a self-proclaimed softball question regarding the speed of change of the cable news business model. Is it feasible to have a non-partisan 24-hour cable news network?
K responded by pointing out that CNN had its most profitable year ever in 2009, concluding six years of double-digit growth. He attributed some of that growth to having about 20 different properties, including international, headline, online, airport, and a dozen or more countries. As for the benefits of this far-flung organization, he said that some of the first reporting on the Chile earthquake had been from CNN Chile.
T: Where’s the growth?
K: Online and mobile have enormous growth potential. The U.S. cable network is a growth area, since it has two fully-distributed networks – CNN & HLN.
T: There are very few independent media companies. What is an example of synergy from being part of Time Warner?
K: Synergy is driven by people. Some of CNN’s best joint efforts have been with HBO, for example, sharing talent, as with Fareed Zakaria on the Mumbai massacres. These efforts are driven by CNN’s relationship with HBO senior executives and can’t be simply mandated by Time Warner senior management. CNN Money is a successful joint effort with Time Inc.
T: Are these relationships a priority driven through the organization?
K: The business lunch should not be under-estimated. These relationships are best created in a non-pressured environment without reference to specific projects.
CNN also has 1000 affiliates, where they are fostering a climate of cooperation. CNN doubled its profit over the last 4 years due to working together with those affiliates. A premium is placed by Jim Walton, head of CNN Worldwide, to create such collaboration.
T: Does CNN employ people as access points between divisions?
K: CNN hadn’t done so previously. Now, however, CNN doing more in online video. There are two people pushing content from CNN into CNN.com, content that is not necessarily suited for TV.
T: CNN benefits from having two sources of revenue – subscribers and advertising. What about competitors who only have one stream?
K: Everyone in media is looking for multiple revenue streams. The model was created by Ted Turner and fostered by Phil Kent, head of Turner Broadcasting.
CNN is in the happy position of being indispensable at times, not always. That has
created a brand association desired by advertisers as well as cable & satellite providers.
CNN therefore has a focus on over-delivering in those situations because there are few
indispensable global brands.
T: With regard to competition, 24-hour cable news is like an umbrella. One can make a great umbrella or simply tell people it’s always raining. CNN ranks only 3rd in the 25-54 demographic, despite its profit in 2009. Is it a flaw to stick with quality?
K: Ratings are only one metric. CNN doesn’t sell any one show or daypart. Instead, it sells the overall reach of the network. The ways it gets ratings are more important than the ratings themselves. It over-delivers on real journalism.
As a result, CNN is number one in cumulative audience – the total number of people watching. In February 2010, CNN US had 100 million viewers, Fox had 91 million. Fox viewers stay longer, so that boosts their ratings. Also, ratings don’t count out-of-home, online, and mobile, further handicapping CNN.
T: Does it bother you to be in 3rd?
K: CNN thinks of itself as being in 1st place with more and higher quality viewers. It is number 1 in digital, both web and mobile, it is the #1 recognized name in international. Competitors, however, try to define cable news as primetime.
The real competition for CNN is actually social networking, especially at night, a phenomenon that has shifted from daytime as being primetime for the web. People on Facebook and Twitter are also sources of news. He wants CNN to be the most trusted source [Note: any recent studies seem to indicate that social networks are losing some credibility as sources of information. He is more worried about Facebook than about Fox.
T: Does he have a social media director?
K: CNN has a social media group, which is not segregated out as separate function. Instead, social media is integrated into everything.
He likened CNN’s move into social networking to the controversy he created as the first person at CBS News to put his email address on his business card. He feels that CNN similarly needs to be accessible and be part of the conversation. People crave information. Because it is easier to get, it creates its own demand. If CNN can solve the complexity, it can make information easier to access.
At the same time, he needs to keep an eye on expenses and quality/
T: What do people want on social networks?
K: People are looking for reliability – is the information true? They will spread nuggets of truth to their friends. Truth is the essential function among social networks. He doesn’t want to cloud CNN’s reliability with suspect partisanship. CNN is the number 1 source in digital due to its reliability.
CNN is the most dependable source of news.
T: Klein says that CNN is non-partisan. The Pew Research Foundation says that CNN’s audience skews Democratic while Fox skews Republican.
K: When you get a large audience, you get all kinds. [Note: this was a particularly non-responsive answer. T was asking about composition, not size, of the audience. Since this issue arises often with regard to CNN and Fox, Klein’s failure to have a more responsive, even if stock, answer, contributed to the sense that much of the discussion was based on the “party line.”]
Profitable businesses can be built around niches. CNN’s niche is people who crave reliable information about world. That niche is underserved due to the proliferation of partisan sources of information. Competitors get fringe audiences, and CNN gets the vast audience who wants dependable news.
T: What is the future of America if sources of news harden along ideological lines?
K: Changes prevent such hardening. Five years ago, there was no Facebook or Twitter. The constant is that people will want reliable sources of information, despite the growth of long tail interests. There needs to be at least some source seen as a non-partisan and straightforward source of information.
CNN has gained 50% more viewers than in the mid-1990s even with more competition. Competition forces you to be better as the audiences demand improvement. Then, the audience spreads the word about what’s good, as with the movie Paranormal Activity. He acknowledged that CNN had gotten criticism about its Iran election protest coverage and asserted that it had improved as a result.
T: CNN has to transition from being a logistics organization to being a reporting organization.
K: In the past, if there was no competition, just getting there to report the news is sufficient. CNN also benefited by airing news when no one else did.
Now, other news organizations can also provide the effect of being there. Depth of analysis is harder since more brainpower and creativity is required. That’s why they put Fareed Zakaria on the air. He would not have had a place on cable news 10 years ago since he’s not just about being there. Similarly, the rise of Ali Velshi is based on providing synthesis of information.
T: Isn’t synthesis similar to opinion?
K: There is a difference between someone who’s actually been somewhere vs. sitting in a cloistered environment and throwing bombs.
Many opinion leaders are informed but do not have the additional credibility of actual experience.
CNN anchors don’t advocate policy. Guests will advocate. He acknowledged that CNN is not perfect.
The best journalistic organizations rarely miss a step, citing 60 Minutes, the Wall St. Journal and Vanity Fair. They provide consistent, in-depth reporting and analysis.
T: Is such journalism possible?
K: The WSJ does it every day. CNN cancelled Crossfire because it had degenerated into mud-throwing. Anything that is around too long eventually becomes a caricature of itself, a circus [Note: Quite a generalization. What about 60 Minutes?]. The creation of the Situation Room program as an island of intelligent discussion resulted from CNN’s assessment of Crossfire.
T: What about stories regarding the balloon boy?
K: CNN always has to cover breaking news. After all, if the boy had been in the balloon, it would have been a disservice to not have covered the story. On the other hand, CNN moves off of a story when it veers into a speculative mode.
While CNN’s coverage included having the parents of balloon boy on Larry King with Wolf Blitzer that night, there was also no other major story competing for CNN’s attention.
In CNN’s defense, it dropped the story in general afterwards even though not everyone else did. Generally, cable news takes a story and speculates about it endlessly.
His experience from launching and running the FeedRoom is that Day 2 of almost any story drops off sharply with regard to audience interest. He is trying to bring that learning to cable news, that the audience tires of a story before the cable news networks do.
As an example, the Congressman Massa story is viewed as generally dead; the audience is already over it. Of course, an errant producer may cover the story anyway.
CNN’s tries to avoid speculative stories. Regarding Tiger Woods, CNN covered the automobile crash. “Once you get the picture, dial back.” CNN purposely did not get into the speculative phase with psychologists, sex addiction counselor, mistresses, etc. CNN tries not to feed that angle. It may be legitimate for other news outlets. CNN would interview Tiger Woods but not anyone who has anything to say about Tiger Woods.
TL: What is more important: good producers or good on-air talent?
K: Both. Producers tend to be deferential to talent. The key is having talent who understands news and producers who can help them achieve the desired quality. Examples include Jeff Zucker and Katie Couric at the Today Show. That symbiosis is why CNN hired Tom Bettag for Candy Crowley. At the same time, he wants viewers to have fun – he doesn’t want CNN to become CSPAN.
Too many producers and talent have been corrupted by the direction the business has gone toward less intelligent discussion and more fireworks. It was exciting when it started, but now everyone does it. There is an oversaturation of the meaningless and trivial. CNN has to deliver something more substantive and serious. By delivering that, CNN will build its audience as it did in 2009.
T: how’s the relationship between CNN and the White House?
K: It’s the way it was before. Some reporters [Note: presumably not at CNN] expected a golden age in White House – journalist relations. CNN pointed out to the news community that the White House is populated by hard-bitten politicians who will use journalists to accomplish their own ends.
Strangely, the White House is fixated on traditional journalistic outlets such mainstream broadcast, e.g. Sunday morning shows. The White House reverted to an old-fashioned media approach despite having won the presidency based on its facility with new media.
The White House mishandled its approach to Fox Networks by criticizing Fox but not attacking MSNBC, which supported them. It didn’t seem statesmanlike.
People are skeptical of authority, and reporters are supposed to do the same – hold the powerful accountable. For that reason, the Millenial generation and other like-minded skeptical audiences should love CNN.
T: How was CNN on the coverage of the financial crisis?
K: Ali Velshi is good at explaining the terminology. CNN could have done more on the issue of accountability for the crisis. The public is not clear on whose fault this is: Why did this happen? Who should we be angry at? CNN, however, doesn’t want to simply fan the flames to public resentment. It doesn’t want to just tap into public anger; it has to enlighten the audience.
TL: Do journalists understand the root causes of the financial crisis? Is that journalists don’t get it or that they can’t explain it?
K: Perhaps no one understands the root causes. The news media should at least set out theories about the causes and dissect and explain them in an intelligent way.
T: At the time of the crisis, should CNN have educated everyone?
K: CNN did launch summits to leverage the assets of Fortune and Money magazines. It had primetime discussions about the economy. But there needs to be significant frequency of programming before people realize you’re even making these sorts of efforts. Therefore, CNN’s new approach is in trying to do fewer things better, e.g., its new show with Ali Velshi.
T: Is there a ceiling on the ability of TV to explain complexity?
K: New technology allows more detailed explanations, such as John King’s electronic board during the 2008 election.
CNN did a study about consumer viewing habits. Consumers were asked about their favorite shows and how often they were viewed. On average, 15% of the episodes of their favorite shows were watched. The Sopranos has the highest score – 36.7% of the episodes were viewed
Therefore, networks have to be consistent due to lack of viewer frequency, and NPR is an example of a consistent news provider.
T: Was Lou Dobbs over the line with his commentaries on public policy?
K: CNN concluded that this is not what it wants to be about. It should let others engage in opinion to that extent.
Lou understood the difference of opinion with his approach. He wants to pursue advocacy journalism so he and CNN parted ways.
T: How does he feel about the depth of competition?
K: Fox fostered a culture of an Alamo-like environment: us against the world. CNN is more focused on all of the things that are changing in the competition for eyeballs. It prefers to engage in competition for quality of journalism, and on that score, feels that it is like the way the Yankees viewed the competition during their years of dominance.
T: What news asset do you most covet?
K: 60 minutes, due to its consistency over time. Executive Producer Jeff Fager updated a classic and took it up in quality, so he watches it all the time.
T: Would CNN do a magazine show?
K: Audiences may not want that format anymore. The preparation time can put you out of sync with the news cycle, even thought CNN does not want to just tell you what happened today.
In 2 years, there has been a 30% increase in the number of people getting their news digitally. To meet that growing demand, CNN will definitely provide additional news formats, such as investigative, long-form and documentaries.
T: Will there be a loss if evening network news shows go away?
K: No. We can’t cling to the forms and formats of the past. We have to question everything. CNN could decide to stay the course or evolve. It shouldn’t be like the ad agency depicted on MadMen, oblivious to the changes that are coming.
There would be no loss because there are so many sources of information. More sources mean that serious journalism is easier to do than before. Of course, journalists may not make the same amount of money as before. He doesn’t know anyone who gets into and stays in journalism for the money - it’s an obsession, not a profession.
Introductory remarks were from Paul Bascobart, the president of Bloomberg BusinessWeek. He started out by saying that this was a particularly interesting year to review business models [Note: aren’t they all lately, and for the foreseeable future as well?] and predicted that the Summit’s sessions would include some “old-fashioned Italian fistfights.” He pointed out, as everyone in the audience presumably knew, that last year’s summit had been held in the midst of the financial crisis. The stock and ad markets were down, and iconic media brands were going out of business.
It was now three months since the acquisition of BusinessWeek magazine by Bloomberg. He proclaimed that they are on the cusp of the relaunch of an exciting new magazine. He said that it was going against the trends of the magazine business – there would be more stories with increased frequency of publication on thicker paper, an integrated newsroom with 2300 reporters, and on April 23, a new.businesweek.com.
He then introduced Josh Tyrangiel, who had joined Bloomberg BusinessWeek as Editor in November from Time, where he had been deputy managing editor at Time magazine and managing editor at Time.com. Josh (T) was to interview Jonathan Klein (K), the president of CNN/US since 2005 as the first event of the Summit.
T offered up a self-proclaimed softball question regarding the speed of change of the cable news business model. Is it feasible to have a non-partisan 24-hour cable news network?
K responded by pointing out that CNN had its most profitable year ever in 2009, concluding six years of double-digit growth. He attributed some of that growth to having about 20 different properties, including international, headline, online, airport, and a dozen or more countries. As for the benefits of this far-flung organization, he said that some of the first reporting on the Chile earthquake had been from CNN Chile.
T: Where’s the growth?
K: Online and mobile have enormous growth potential. The U.S. cable network is a growth area, since it has two fully-distributed networks – CNN & HLN.
T: There are very few independent media companies. What is an example of synergy from being part of Time Warner?
K: Synergy is driven by people. Some of CNN’s best joint efforts have been with HBO, for example, sharing talent, as with Fareed Zakaria on the Mumbai massacres. These efforts are driven by CNN’s relationship with HBO senior executives and can’t be simply mandated by Time Warner senior management. CNN Money is a successful joint effort with Time Inc.
T: Are these relationships a priority driven through the organization?
K: The business lunch should not be under-estimated. These relationships are best created in a non-pressured environment without reference to specific projects.
CNN also has 1000 affiliates, where they are fostering a climate of cooperation. CNN doubled its profit over the last 4 years due to working together with those affiliates. A premium is placed by Jim Walton, head of CNN Worldwide, to create such collaboration.
T: Does CNN employ people as access points between divisions?
K: CNN hadn’t done so previously. Now, however, CNN doing more in online video. There are two people pushing content from CNN into CNN.com, content that is not necessarily suited for TV.
T: CNN benefits from having two sources of revenue – subscribers and advertising. What about competitors who only have one stream?
K: Everyone in media is looking for multiple revenue streams. The model was created by Ted Turner and fostered by Phil Kent, head of Turner Broadcasting.
CNN is in the happy position of being indispensable at times, not always. That has
created a brand association desired by advertisers as well as cable & satellite providers.
CNN therefore has a focus on over-delivering in those situations because there are few
indispensable global brands.
T: With regard to competition, 24-hour cable news is like an umbrella. One can make a great umbrella or simply tell people it’s always raining. CNN ranks only 3rd in the 25-54 demographic, despite its profit in 2009. Is it a flaw to stick with quality?
K: Ratings are only one metric. CNN doesn’t sell any one show or daypart. Instead, it sells the overall reach of the network. The ways it gets ratings are more important than the ratings themselves. It over-delivers on real journalism.
As a result, CNN is number one in cumulative audience – the total number of people watching. In February 2010, CNN US had 100 million viewers, Fox had 91 million. Fox viewers stay longer, so that boosts their ratings. Also, ratings don’t count out-of-home, online, and mobile, further handicapping CNN.
T: Does it bother you to be in 3rd?
K: CNN thinks of itself as being in 1st place with more and higher quality viewers. It is number 1 in digital, both web and mobile, it is the #1 recognized name in international. Competitors, however, try to define cable news as primetime.
The real competition for CNN is actually social networking, especially at night, a phenomenon that has shifted from daytime as being primetime for the web. People on Facebook and Twitter are also sources of news. He wants CNN to be the most trusted source [Note: any recent studies seem to indicate that social networks are losing some credibility as sources of information. He is more worried about Facebook than about Fox.
T: Does he have a social media director?
K: CNN has a social media group, which is not segregated out as separate function. Instead, social media is integrated into everything.
He likened CNN’s move into social networking to the controversy he created as the first person at CBS News to put his email address on his business card. He feels that CNN similarly needs to be accessible and be part of the conversation. People crave information. Because it is easier to get, it creates its own demand. If CNN can solve the complexity, it can make information easier to access.
At the same time, he needs to keep an eye on expenses and quality/
T: What do people want on social networks?
K: People are looking for reliability – is the information true? They will spread nuggets of truth to their friends. Truth is the essential function among social networks. He doesn’t want to cloud CNN’s reliability with suspect partisanship. CNN is the number 1 source in digital due to its reliability.
CNN is the most dependable source of news.
T: Klein says that CNN is non-partisan. The Pew Research Foundation says that CNN’s audience skews Democratic while Fox skews Republican.
K: When you get a large audience, you get all kinds. [Note: this was a particularly non-responsive answer. T was asking about composition, not size, of the audience. Since this issue arises often with regard to CNN and Fox, Klein’s failure to have a more responsive, even if stock, answer, contributed to the sense that much of the discussion was based on the “party line.”]
Profitable businesses can be built around niches. CNN’s niche is people who crave reliable information about world. That niche is underserved due to the proliferation of partisan sources of information. Competitors get fringe audiences, and CNN gets the vast audience who wants dependable news.
T: What is the future of America if sources of news harden along ideological lines?
K: Changes prevent such hardening. Five years ago, there was no Facebook or Twitter. The constant is that people will want reliable sources of information, despite the growth of long tail interests. There needs to be at least some source seen as a non-partisan and straightforward source of information.
CNN has gained 50% more viewers than in the mid-1990s even with more competition. Competition forces you to be better as the audiences demand improvement. Then, the audience spreads the word about what’s good, as with the movie Paranormal Activity. He acknowledged that CNN had gotten criticism about its Iran election protest coverage and asserted that it had improved as a result.
T: CNN has to transition from being a logistics organization to being a reporting organization.
K: In the past, if there was no competition, just getting there to report the news is sufficient. CNN also benefited by airing news when no one else did.
Now, other news organizations can also provide the effect of being there. Depth of analysis is harder since more brainpower and creativity is required. That’s why they put Fareed Zakaria on the air. He would not have had a place on cable news 10 years ago since he’s not just about being there. Similarly, the rise of Ali Velshi is based on providing synthesis of information.
T: Isn’t synthesis similar to opinion?
K: There is a difference between someone who’s actually been somewhere vs. sitting in a cloistered environment and throwing bombs.
Many opinion leaders are informed but do not have the additional credibility of actual experience.
CNN anchors don’t advocate policy. Guests will advocate. He acknowledged that CNN is not perfect.
The best journalistic organizations rarely miss a step, citing 60 Minutes, the Wall St. Journal and Vanity Fair. They provide consistent, in-depth reporting and analysis.
T: Is such journalism possible?
K: The WSJ does it every day. CNN cancelled Crossfire because it had degenerated into mud-throwing. Anything that is around too long eventually becomes a caricature of itself, a circus [Note: Quite a generalization. What about 60 Minutes?]. The creation of the Situation Room program as an island of intelligent discussion resulted from CNN’s assessment of Crossfire.
T: What about stories regarding the balloon boy?
K: CNN always has to cover breaking news. After all, if the boy had been in the balloon, it would have been a disservice to not have covered the story. On the other hand, CNN moves off of a story when it veers into a speculative mode.
While CNN’s coverage included having the parents of balloon boy on Larry King with Wolf Blitzer that night, there was also no other major story competing for CNN’s attention.
In CNN’s defense, it dropped the story in general afterwards even though not everyone else did. Generally, cable news takes a story and speculates about it endlessly.
His experience from launching and running the FeedRoom is that Day 2 of almost any story drops off sharply with regard to audience interest. He is trying to bring that learning to cable news, that the audience tires of a story before the cable news networks do.
As an example, the Congressman Massa story is viewed as generally dead; the audience is already over it. Of course, an errant producer may cover the story anyway.
CNN’s tries to avoid speculative stories. Regarding Tiger Woods, CNN covered the automobile crash. “Once you get the picture, dial back.” CNN purposely did not get into the speculative phase with psychologists, sex addiction counselor, mistresses, etc. CNN tries not to feed that angle. It may be legitimate for other news outlets. CNN would interview Tiger Woods but not anyone who has anything to say about Tiger Woods.
TL: What is more important: good producers or good on-air talent?
K: Both. Producers tend to be deferential to talent. The key is having talent who understands news and producers who can help them achieve the desired quality. Examples include Jeff Zucker and Katie Couric at the Today Show. That symbiosis is why CNN hired Tom Bettag for Candy Crowley. At the same time, he wants viewers to have fun – he doesn’t want CNN to become CSPAN.
Too many producers and talent have been corrupted by the direction the business has gone toward less intelligent discussion and more fireworks. It was exciting when it started, but now everyone does it. There is an oversaturation of the meaningless and trivial. CNN has to deliver something more substantive and serious. By delivering that, CNN will build its audience as it did in 2009.
T: how’s the relationship between CNN and the White House?
K: It’s the way it was before. Some reporters [Note: presumably not at CNN] expected a golden age in White House – journalist relations. CNN pointed out to the news community that the White House is populated by hard-bitten politicians who will use journalists to accomplish their own ends.
Strangely, the White House is fixated on traditional journalistic outlets such mainstream broadcast, e.g. Sunday morning shows. The White House reverted to an old-fashioned media approach despite having won the presidency based on its facility with new media.
The White House mishandled its approach to Fox Networks by criticizing Fox but not attacking MSNBC, which supported them. It didn’t seem statesmanlike.
People are skeptical of authority, and reporters are supposed to do the same – hold the powerful accountable. For that reason, the Millenial generation and other like-minded skeptical audiences should love CNN.
T: How was CNN on the coverage of the financial crisis?
K: Ali Velshi is good at explaining the terminology. CNN could have done more on the issue of accountability for the crisis. The public is not clear on whose fault this is: Why did this happen? Who should we be angry at? CNN, however, doesn’t want to simply fan the flames to public resentment. It doesn’t want to just tap into public anger; it has to enlighten the audience.
TL: Do journalists understand the root causes of the financial crisis? Is that journalists don’t get it or that they can’t explain it?
K: Perhaps no one understands the root causes. The news media should at least set out theories about the causes and dissect and explain them in an intelligent way.
T: At the time of the crisis, should CNN have educated everyone?
K: CNN did launch summits to leverage the assets of Fortune and Money magazines. It had primetime discussions about the economy. But there needs to be significant frequency of programming before people realize you’re even making these sorts of efforts. Therefore, CNN’s new approach is in trying to do fewer things better, e.g., its new show with Ali Velshi.
T: Is there a ceiling on the ability of TV to explain complexity?
K: New technology allows more detailed explanations, such as John King’s electronic board during the 2008 election.
CNN did a study about consumer viewing habits. Consumers were asked about their favorite shows and how often they were viewed. On average, 15% of the episodes of their favorite shows were watched. The Sopranos has the highest score – 36.7% of the episodes were viewed
Therefore, networks have to be consistent due to lack of viewer frequency, and NPR is an example of a consistent news provider.
T: Was Lou Dobbs over the line with his commentaries on public policy?
K: CNN concluded that this is not what it wants to be about. It should let others engage in opinion to that extent.
Lou understood the difference of opinion with his approach. He wants to pursue advocacy journalism so he and CNN parted ways.
T: How does he feel about the depth of competition?
K: Fox fostered a culture of an Alamo-like environment: us against the world. CNN is more focused on all of the things that are changing in the competition for eyeballs. It prefers to engage in competition for quality of journalism, and on that score, feels that it is like the way the Yankees viewed the competition during their years of dominance.
T: What news asset do you most covet?
K: 60 minutes, due to its consistency over time. Executive Producer Jeff Fager updated a classic and took it up in quality, so he watches it all the time.
T: Would CNN do a magazine show?
K: Audiences may not want that format anymore. The preparation time can put you out of sync with the news cycle, even thought CNN does not want to just tell you what happened today.
In 2 years, there has been a 30% increase in the number of people getting their news digitally. To meet that growing demand, CNN will definitely provide additional news formats, such as investigative, long-form and documentaries.
T: Will there be a loss if evening network news shows go away?
K: No. We can’t cling to the forms and formats of the past. We have to question everything. CNN could decide to stay the course or evolve. It shouldn’t be like the ad agency depicted on MadMen, oblivious to the changes that are coming.
There would be no loss because there are so many sources of information. More sources mean that serious journalism is easier to do than before. Of course, journalists may not make the same amount of money as before. He doesn’t know anyone who gets into and stays in journalism for the money - it’s an obsession, not a profession.
Saturday, February 20, 2010
SobelMedia: Uncorking Gary Vaynerchuk: an interview by Ellis Henican
I attended SobelMedia’s latest event, an interview of Gary Vaynerchuk by journalist http://henican.com/ of Newsday and Fox News on the evening of February 17, 2010 at the Samsung Experience at the Time Warner Center.
Gary Vaynerchuk has become a leading online and social media celebrity with his outspoken personality, relentless promotion, and savvy use of the latest online and offline marketing platforms. These include Twitter, his Wine Library TV website, and his book, Crush It.
My notes are below, with the caveats that they are my best rendition of the discussion, with no claim to accuracy; much of the discussion has been paraphrased, rather than being a direct quote of the participants; and I bring my own viewpoint and perspective to this discussion, which influences my perception of the discussion.
Bill got the event started by reminiscing that he has began his breakfast events in June 2006 in a coffee shop hear Grand Central [with yours truly among those in attendance]. His efforts had grown into must-attend gatherings for those who want to stay abreast of the latest developments in media. While he had started with breakfast events, due to some feedback regarding the early morning start times for those events, he announced that he was now launching evening events, with this being the kickoff.
He thanked his sponsors, including Definition 6/Creative Bubble, Samsung, TrylonSMR and Sunshine Suites. He also mentioned the Levin Institute’s Jumpstart Program for entrepreneurs and startups and said that he enjoys being involved with their efforts. He also lauded Bouchon Bakery, who catered this evening’s event [the turkey sandwich was my favorite - even beat out my perennial preference: pastrami].
Bill announced his next event – a breakfast on March 18 discussing women in media and marketing – before turning the stage over for the introduction of the evening’s participants by Jeff Katz (JK), the president and COO of Definition 6, Bill’s colleague and primary sponsor.
JK started off by saying that he couldn’t think of three people with more passion than Bill Sobel, Ellis Henican & Gary Vaynerchuk. He pointed out that there were many ways to connect with Gary – you could read his book, find him on Facebook, follow him on Twitter, watch his online TV show, etc. Gary, who was born in Belarus and raised in New Jersey, had started by selling gas grills but realized that people didn’t actually buy grills, they bought the social experiences that were created by the grills – cookouts, barbecues and parties.
JK then introduced Ellis Henican (E), the moderator for tonight’s event.
E noted that he was from Louisiana and that he had given some advice to Harold Ford, Jr., the former Tennessee congressman expected to run for the U.S. Senate this year. E told Ford to not lose his Southern accent since it created low expectations and a vital advantage in his upcoming election campaign.
Turning to the evening’s guest, E pointed out that Gary Vaynerchuk (G) is a wine guy, first of all. E proclaimed him to be the first wine guru of the internet age. While Forbes had selected G as one of the 25 most influential people on the internet, E suggested that G should probably be in top 5. In large measure, E felt that G warranted this acclaim for having taken something in the real world and having found a new life for it in this new world.
E began by asking: would it have been possible to create such buzz in another retail line, or is it all about the wine as a unique product?
G attributed his success to his mother having brainwashed him into thinking that he was smartest and best-looking person in the world. He viewed his upbringing as the perfect storm – he grew up with nothing, and his mother gave him confidence. He is passionate about wine as well as being hungry and ambitious. In fact, he wants to buy the New York Jets. He also views himself as a born storyteller, and this new world allows him to tell any story he wants without any editor or agent. While everyone can step up to plate, not all of us will hit home runs. He views his success as having come from building his brand and then having celebrity come to him, as realized through his many media appearances, including with Conan O’Brien, Ellen Degeneres, and others.
What’s important is that we have the internet, which is only 15 years old. While we can’t yet wrap our head around it, that’s where the opportunity lies.
E: Is all of this due to the opportunity or his personality?
G: He “worked his ass off and executed.” His platform is video: ninety thousand people watch his wine show daily. Others may have other platforms that they can exploit, such as text or audio.
While his show is only four years old, he studied wine for 15 years before his first episode, so subject knowledge is important. He sees himself as being “over-the-top patient” in having developed his brand.
E agreed that G may be nuts, but he certainly cares about wine.
G amended that to argue that he really cares about people: “When you give a crap, the whole game changes.” He said that he originally spent 12 hours per day searching for, and responding to, wine-related questions on Twitter in building his brand.
We live in a day and age where we can care first. He said he is obsessed with customer service. His next book will be titled The Thank You Economy. His first book, Crush It, had been expected to flop since other social network books had failed. Since all of his original outreach had been free, he felt that people had bought his book in order to thank him.
E: The audience is probably asking: how can I use personal branding for myself?
G: Not everyone is meant to be a personal brand. If you don’t like people, you can’t be a brand in social media.
Truth is the most important thing, even if is negative. As a result, he estimated that 85% of people like him, but 15% find him too East Coast or too much energy. He seemed comfortable with that proportion since he feels that he knows himself and how he’s wired. His happiness is simplistic: he likes the climb. He said that when he was younger, he followed the Yankees and the Rangers until they won championships. After that, he lost interest because he is all about the process.
He proclaimed that he knew that his efforts would work because he really cares about people. His platform is shockingly transparent; there is no hiding. Even if he were to be viewed as a jerk, he said he would work hard enough to succeed.
E: In the dark night of his soul, what does he worry about?
G: The only thing that remotely scares him is the health of his family. He asserted that he definitely has “business chops” – he always knew how to make money, just as LeBron James & Tiger Woods clearly have superior skills in their respective sports. G said he knows how to sell and give customer service. He also said that he is also to foresee social trends, and that he provides value to consumer products companies by consulting with them on ways to extend their marketing campaigns beyond TV.
He knows what people say that they’re not going to do and that they do anyway, citing those, particularly in the audience, who had once said that they would never have Facebook pages or carry cellphones. He said that when he saw Twitter in 2006, while others dismissed it simply as a way to transmit the news about one’s lunch choices, he immediately recognized it as a word-of-mouth tool. Therefore, he went all in to take advantage of the platform. He said that he will now invest and make money when he sees similar things that he feels will catch on.
E: Traditional businesses are struggling in converting to new models. Are they doomed?
G: People don’t always see changes coming, and many bought horses before Henry Ford had his good idea. Are businesses doomed? Maybe. At the least, they are naïve if don’t see that things are changing.
On the flip side, everyone is acting like “teen-aged dudes” in that they are not taking the long-term perspective. There is a difference between “hooking up and marriage,” and too many players are too concerned about closing/hooking-up rather than on building relationships.
Ecosystems are built on word of mouth and relationships. In the past, new technologies enabled marketers to buy relationships through mass media. Now, as relationships depend on actual connections, they are finding that the new media does not enable them to buy friends.
E pointed out the seeming irony of G giving away his material on the new media platforms and making money by means of old media, such as books.
G: He is not romanced by or committed to any particular platform. Instead, he is simply obsessed with his message and getting it in front of people. He wrote a book because people still read books. Therefore, he doesn’t worry about adjusting to the new platforms because they can all be conduits for his message.
He doesn’t draw lines in the sand and instead adjusts to reality. You can’t bet on what you wish things to be instead of adjusting to what’s actually happening.
E: In getting your message out, should you be in all places?
G: As many as you can handle.
At this point, E threw the discussion open to questions from the audience. Many were prefaced by gushing kudos, which have been omitted in the interest of space [mild joke].
Q: Is he interested in investing internationally?
G: London has lot of interesting startups. His objective is to get into niches. He is obsessed with geolocation and feels that, while people do not yet understand the value of constantly “checking in” regarding their locations, marketers will make it worthwhile for consumers to do so. He is willing to look at companies worldwide in that space.
Q: Is the video image quality good enough for his episodic videos?
E: Google and Yahoo flew him out to their headquarters because they wanted to understand how he succeeded when his videos were 25 minutes long in contrast to most videos being only 3 minutes. Content is the “obnoxious king.” He concedes that his video quality is poor: done in one take with no microphone and bad lighting. He proclaimed himself to be in the ghetto of online video shows that do well.
He also felt that we are about to embark on a gold rush of online video because of smart TVs. When people can get online videos on TV, the economic leverage between the audience and the TV providers changes. He feels that there is a race between HDTV penetration into the households and HDTV on PCs and mobile.
Q: What does he think of Burger King and Starbucks partnering with their complementary brands?
E: He consults for entrepreneurs and Fortune 500 companies. Business development is attractive – defined as leveraging each others’ audiences – especially because entrepreneurs generally don’t already have their own audiences. Similarly, he is willing to use his brand equity to assist newer, less-developed brands, such as by granting interviews for unknown blogs to help them build their audiences.
Business development is the most under-rated thing right now. 4Square is ahead of Ooyala (where he is an investor?) because of their business development efforts at promoting themselves. Old-school brands need to leverage their brands while they still have value.
In many cases, such as HuffPo, Facebook and others, new media brands have caught up to old established brands and will surpass them.
He is fascinated by the question of brand equity and how it is leveraged. Most people are sales people, not marketers, returning to his earlier theme that people are generally not patient, looking to hookup rather than building relationships.
The question for new technology in building relationships should be: what’s our story?
Q: What tools does he use for Twitter?
G: He admitted to not being efficient despite the chaos of Twitter. He uses Tweetdeck and will try Seesmic. He pointed out that people, presumably including him, get stuck in habits. As an example, people often type in “Google” into a URL rather than using the on-screen search function in the upper right hand corner of Firefox.
Q: How does he feel about multimedia and the iPad?
G: The amount of work he does on the toilet is shocking [biggest laugh of the evening]. He has not yet used the iPad. The most interesting thing about the iPad is that consumers are trying to figure out why they’re going to use it. That means Apple has built a brand. He said that Apple could probably sell an iHammer even if people have no idea why they need it.
Similarly, people like television and won’t get away from it. Therefore, the entertainment industry will go upside down when all content becomes available immediately on demand on the television.
Q: What is his consulting business model?
G: When asked by clients how to measure success, his response was that he would feel it. He “massively dislikes” SEO and analytics. He feels it is important to “live his business.” He pointed out that billboard metrics are unreliable, being based on cars passing a display, and that magazines charge on number printed [as an alumnus of Time Inc., I must say that this comment is not true, but the actual metrics are not necessarily any more accurate].
When dealing with big brands looking for the ROI of new media, he points out that they hadn’t yet figured out the real ROI of old media.
At the same time, he feels that social media is the most measurable medium because it can create and measure a call to action. He is, however, not interested in convincing people about social media. He generated tremendous sales for his book Crush It without traditional media, so he is not interested in proving anything. He wants to simply do it and let other people catch up.
Q: How can someone create a tipping point with their content to generate audiences?
G: The first step is to care about the audience. Content is the smallest part of the equation. He attributes his success, not to the daily 25 minutes on TV, but to the 15 hours he spends each day creating the community.
Suggestions: go to other blogs, become part of the conversation. He says that he uses Search on Twitter and looks at and responds to @GaryV results every day. He responds to every item, in contrast to the 99% of people in business who don’t care about their customer.
He cited the example of Zappos, who succeeds because it cares about the customer. Success does not require complete and total care of the customer, just more than the standard that customers are used to.
These efforts to create a community via customer service will provide an umbrella of protection for the brand. This wouldn’t have mattered as much years ago before customers could communicate negative experiences easily. [An example that gained traction immediately after G’s interview: Kevin Smith’s treatment by Southwest Airlines – an item that would not have gotten as much traction without the immediacy of Twitter.]
Q: What should Obama do with social media?
G: Regardless of one’s political position, Obama should be using social media to make him as authentically real as possible. G feels that Obama “missed the boat.” While conceding that Obama can’t use all of the social media tools due to security and other concerns, he needs to be transparent and that people will accept anything under those circumstances.
He feels that Obama did a poor job during campaign because the campaign didn’t make it obvious that the Tweeting wasn’t done by him, and people thought it actually was him.
Q: Where is TV going?
G: It will make strides in interactive, 3D and video telephony. He is interested in the future of cable TV because they sell bundled services against the wishes of the consumers, which he considers communistic. While cable companies may own the internet for the moment by providing connectivity, wireless is the future.
People only look one step forward and have to really look at where things are going.
He expects that one of the cable companies will go a la carte and the whole cable business will crumple. Nobody wants to crumble their monopoly, and they do so only when they have to.
E: Will consumers pay?
G: Apps have created a culture that consumers will pay. They have changed the conversation from only getting things for free. The freemium model is also going strong.
Facebook made a mistake by allowing others to build app platforms for virtual goods. The should have kept control of that marketplace, as a South Korean platform did, and they could have been making billions on virtual currency instead of ceding that market to Zanga.
Twitter should have been a freemium model, and they could have gone from free to revenue.
The value is in capturing audience, which can always be monetized later.
Q: In developing startups, should the focus be on the customer or on making money?
G: The way you make real money is by focusing on real relationships.
As an aside, he thought it was fascinating when the markets crashed because he didn’t recognize how soft we really are. He was scornful of people who were crying simply because we could no longer buy as much stuff as before. His approach is to pull up your bootstraps, buy less stuff, and work hard.
VL: That’s a good sentiment for any day and age.
Gary Vaynerchuk has become a leading online and social media celebrity with his outspoken personality, relentless promotion, and savvy use of the latest online and offline marketing platforms. These include Twitter, his Wine Library TV website, and his book, Crush It.
My notes are below, with the caveats that they are my best rendition of the discussion, with no claim to accuracy; much of the discussion has been paraphrased, rather than being a direct quote of the participants; and I bring my own viewpoint and perspective to this discussion, which influences my perception of the discussion.
Bill got the event started by reminiscing that he has began his breakfast events in June 2006 in a coffee shop hear Grand Central [with yours truly among those in attendance]. His efforts had grown into must-attend gatherings for those who want to stay abreast of the latest developments in media. While he had started with breakfast events, due to some feedback regarding the early morning start times for those events, he announced that he was now launching evening events, with this being the kickoff.
He thanked his sponsors, including Definition 6/Creative Bubble, Samsung, TrylonSMR and Sunshine Suites. He also mentioned the Levin Institute’s Jumpstart Program for entrepreneurs and startups and said that he enjoys being involved with their efforts. He also lauded Bouchon Bakery, who catered this evening’s event [the turkey sandwich was my favorite - even beat out my perennial preference: pastrami].
Bill announced his next event – a breakfast on March 18 discussing women in media and marketing – before turning the stage over for the introduction of the evening’s participants by Jeff Katz (JK), the president and COO of Definition 6, Bill’s colleague and primary sponsor.
JK started off by saying that he couldn’t think of three people with more passion than Bill Sobel, Ellis Henican & Gary Vaynerchuk. He pointed out that there were many ways to connect with Gary – you could read his book, find him on Facebook, follow him on Twitter, watch his online TV show, etc. Gary, who was born in Belarus and raised in New Jersey, had started by selling gas grills but realized that people didn’t actually buy grills, they bought the social experiences that were created by the grills – cookouts, barbecues and parties.
JK then introduced Ellis Henican (E), the moderator for tonight’s event.
E noted that he was from Louisiana and that he had given some advice to Harold Ford, Jr., the former Tennessee congressman expected to run for the U.S. Senate this year. E told Ford to not lose his Southern accent since it created low expectations and a vital advantage in his upcoming election campaign.
Turning to the evening’s guest, E pointed out that Gary Vaynerchuk (G) is a wine guy, first of all. E proclaimed him to be the first wine guru of the internet age. While Forbes had selected G as one of the 25 most influential people on the internet, E suggested that G should probably be in top 5. In large measure, E felt that G warranted this acclaim for having taken something in the real world and having found a new life for it in this new world.
E began by asking: would it have been possible to create such buzz in another retail line, or is it all about the wine as a unique product?
G attributed his success to his mother having brainwashed him into thinking that he was smartest and best-looking person in the world. He viewed his upbringing as the perfect storm – he grew up with nothing, and his mother gave him confidence. He is passionate about wine as well as being hungry and ambitious. In fact, he wants to buy the New York Jets. He also views himself as a born storyteller, and this new world allows him to tell any story he wants without any editor or agent. While everyone can step up to plate, not all of us will hit home runs. He views his success as having come from building his brand and then having celebrity come to him, as realized through his many media appearances, including with Conan O’Brien, Ellen Degeneres, and others.
What’s important is that we have the internet, which is only 15 years old. While we can’t yet wrap our head around it, that’s where the opportunity lies.
E: Is all of this due to the opportunity or his personality?
G: He “worked his ass off and executed.” His platform is video: ninety thousand people watch his wine show daily. Others may have other platforms that they can exploit, such as text or audio.
While his show is only four years old, he studied wine for 15 years before his first episode, so subject knowledge is important. He sees himself as being “over-the-top patient” in having developed his brand.
E agreed that G may be nuts, but he certainly cares about wine.
G amended that to argue that he really cares about people: “When you give a crap, the whole game changes.” He said that he originally spent 12 hours per day searching for, and responding to, wine-related questions on Twitter in building his brand.
We live in a day and age where we can care first. He said he is obsessed with customer service. His next book will be titled The Thank You Economy. His first book, Crush It, had been expected to flop since other social network books had failed. Since all of his original outreach had been free, he felt that people had bought his book in order to thank him.
E: The audience is probably asking: how can I use personal branding for myself?
G: Not everyone is meant to be a personal brand. If you don’t like people, you can’t be a brand in social media.
Truth is the most important thing, even if is negative. As a result, he estimated that 85% of people like him, but 15% find him too East Coast or too much energy. He seemed comfortable with that proportion since he feels that he knows himself and how he’s wired. His happiness is simplistic: he likes the climb. He said that when he was younger, he followed the Yankees and the Rangers until they won championships. After that, he lost interest because he is all about the process.
He proclaimed that he knew that his efforts would work because he really cares about people. His platform is shockingly transparent; there is no hiding. Even if he were to be viewed as a jerk, he said he would work hard enough to succeed.
E: In the dark night of his soul, what does he worry about?
G: The only thing that remotely scares him is the health of his family. He asserted that he definitely has “business chops” – he always knew how to make money, just as LeBron James & Tiger Woods clearly have superior skills in their respective sports. G said he knows how to sell and give customer service. He also said that he is also to foresee social trends, and that he provides value to consumer products companies by consulting with them on ways to extend their marketing campaigns beyond TV.
He knows what people say that they’re not going to do and that they do anyway, citing those, particularly in the audience, who had once said that they would never have Facebook pages or carry cellphones. He said that when he saw Twitter in 2006, while others dismissed it simply as a way to transmit the news about one’s lunch choices, he immediately recognized it as a word-of-mouth tool. Therefore, he went all in to take advantage of the platform. He said that he will now invest and make money when he sees similar things that he feels will catch on.
E: Traditional businesses are struggling in converting to new models. Are they doomed?
G: People don’t always see changes coming, and many bought horses before Henry Ford had his good idea. Are businesses doomed? Maybe. At the least, they are naïve if don’t see that things are changing.
On the flip side, everyone is acting like “teen-aged dudes” in that they are not taking the long-term perspective. There is a difference between “hooking up and marriage,” and too many players are too concerned about closing/hooking-up rather than on building relationships.
Ecosystems are built on word of mouth and relationships. In the past, new technologies enabled marketers to buy relationships through mass media. Now, as relationships depend on actual connections, they are finding that the new media does not enable them to buy friends.
E pointed out the seeming irony of G giving away his material on the new media platforms and making money by means of old media, such as books.
G: He is not romanced by or committed to any particular platform. Instead, he is simply obsessed with his message and getting it in front of people. He wrote a book because people still read books. Therefore, he doesn’t worry about adjusting to the new platforms because they can all be conduits for his message.
He doesn’t draw lines in the sand and instead adjusts to reality. You can’t bet on what you wish things to be instead of adjusting to what’s actually happening.
E: In getting your message out, should you be in all places?
G: As many as you can handle.
At this point, E threw the discussion open to questions from the audience. Many were prefaced by gushing kudos, which have been omitted in the interest of space [mild joke].
Q: Is he interested in investing internationally?
G: London has lot of interesting startups. His objective is to get into niches. He is obsessed with geolocation and feels that, while people do not yet understand the value of constantly “checking in” regarding their locations, marketers will make it worthwhile for consumers to do so. He is willing to look at companies worldwide in that space.
Q: Is the video image quality good enough for his episodic videos?
E: Google and Yahoo flew him out to their headquarters because they wanted to understand how he succeeded when his videos were 25 minutes long in contrast to most videos being only 3 minutes. Content is the “obnoxious king.” He concedes that his video quality is poor: done in one take with no microphone and bad lighting. He proclaimed himself to be in the ghetto of online video shows that do well.
He also felt that we are about to embark on a gold rush of online video because of smart TVs. When people can get online videos on TV, the economic leverage between the audience and the TV providers changes. He feels that there is a race between HDTV penetration into the households and HDTV on PCs and mobile.
Q: What does he think of Burger King and Starbucks partnering with their complementary brands?
E: He consults for entrepreneurs and Fortune 500 companies. Business development is attractive – defined as leveraging each others’ audiences – especially because entrepreneurs generally don’t already have their own audiences. Similarly, he is willing to use his brand equity to assist newer, less-developed brands, such as by granting interviews for unknown blogs to help them build their audiences.
Business development is the most under-rated thing right now. 4Square is ahead of Ooyala (where he is an investor?) because of their business development efforts at promoting themselves. Old-school brands need to leverage their brands while they still have value.
In many cases, such as HuffPo, Facebook and others, new media brands have caught up to old established brands and will surpass them.
He is fascinated by the question of brand equity and how it is leveraged. Most people are sales people, not marketers, returning to his earlier theme that people are generally not patient, looking to hookup rather than building relationships.
The question for new technology in building relationships should be: what’s our story?
Q: What tools does he use for Twitter?
G: He admitted to not being efficient despite the chaos of Twitter. He uses Tweetdeck and will try Seesmic. He pointed out that people, presumably including him, get stuck in habits. As an example, people often type in “Google” into a URL rather than using the on-screen search function in the upper right hand corner of Firefox.
Q: How does he feel about multimedia and the iPad?
G: The amount of work he does on the toilet is shocking [biggest laugh of the evening]. He has not yet used the iPad. The most interesting thing about the iPad is that consumers are trying to figure out why they’re going to use it. That means Apple has built a brand. He said that Apple could probably sell an iHammer even if people have no idea why they need it.
Similarly, people like television and won’t get away from it. Therefore, the entertainment industry will go upside down when all content becomes available immediately on demand on the television.
Q: What is his consulting business model?
G: When asked by clients how to measure success, his response was that he would feel it. He “massively dislikes” SEO and analytics. He feels it is important to “live his business.” He pointed out that billboard metrics are unreliable, being based on cars passing a display, and that magazines charge on number printed [as an alumnus of Time Inc., I must say that this comment is not true, but the actual metrics are not necessarily any more accurate].
When dealing with big brands looking for the ROI of new media, he points out that they hadn’t yet figured out the real ROI of old media.
At the same time, he feels that social media is the most measurable medium because it can create and measure a call to action. He is, however, not interested in convincing people about social media. He generated tremendous sales for his book Crush It without traditional media, so he is not interested in proving anything. He wants to simply do it and let other people catch up.
Q: How can someone create a tipping point with their content to generate audiences?
G: The first step is to care about the audience. Content is the smallest part of the equation. He attributes his success, not to the daily 25 minutes on TV, but to the 15 hours he spends each day creating the community.
Suggestions: go to other blogs, become part of the conversation. He says that he uses Search on Twitter and looks at and responds to @GaryV results every day. He responds to every item, in contrast to the 99% of people in business who don’t care about their customer.
He cited the example of Zappos, who succeeds because it cares about the customer. Success does not require complete and total care of the customer, just more than the standard that customers are used to.
These efforts to create a community via customer service will provide an umbrella of protection for the brand. This wouldn’t have mattered as much years ago before customers could communicate negative experiences easily. [An example that gained traction immediately after G’s interview: Kevin Smith’s treatment by Southwest Airlines – an item that would not have gotten as much traction without the immediacy of Twitter.]
Q: What should Obama do with social media?
G: Regardless of one’s political position, Obama should be using social media to make him as authentically real as possible. G feels that Obama “missed the boat.” While conceding that Obama can’t use all of the social media tools due to security and other concerns, he needs to be transparent and that people will accept anything under those circumstances.
He feels that Obama did a poor job during campaign because the campaign didn’t make it obvious that the Tweeting wasn’t done by him, and people thought it actually was him.
Q: Where is TV going?
G: It will make strides in interactive, 3D and video telephony. He is interested in the future of cable TV because they sell bundled services against the wishes of the consumers, which he considers communistic. While cable companies may own the internet for the moment by providing connectivity, wireless is the future.
People only look one step forward and have to really look at where things are going.
He expects that one of the cable companies will go a la carte and the whole cable business will crumple. Nobody wants to crumble their monopoly, and they do so only when they have to.
E: Will consumers pay?
G: Apps have created a culture that consumers will pay. They have changed the conversation from only getting things for free. The freemium model is also going strong.
Facebook made a mistake by allowing others to build app platforms for virtual goods. The should have kept control of that marketplace, as a South Korean platform did, and they could have been making billions on virtual currency instead of ceding that market to Zanga.
Twitter should have been a freemium model, and they could have gone from free to revenue.
The value is in capturing audience, which can always be monetized later.
Q: In developing startups, should the focus be on the customer or on making money?
G: The way you make real money is by focusing on real relationships.
As an aside, he thought it was fascinating when the markets crashed because he didn’t recognize how soft we really are. He was scornful of people who were crying simply because we could no longer buy as much stuff as before. His approach is to pull up your bootstraps, buy less stuff, and work hard.
VL: That’s a good sentiment for any day and age.
Sunday, February 14, 2010
We See What We Want to See
I have been on a potentially masochistic trend lately - reading about how humans are more irrational, less perceptive, and not nearly as clever as we believe ourselves to be. Of course, by "humans," I mean every living member of the species Homo Sapiens other than yours truly. I of course would never be fooled by mere parlor tricks, bamboozled by a grifter's flim-flam, and fail to apply anything other than the keenest of senses and intellect to every endeavor I deign to undertake.
Of course, it's Sunday, the day traditionally set aside, by Christians at least, as a day of rest in which we do not allow worldly concerns to sully our spiritual uplift. In any case, that's my excuse and I'm sticking to it.
I'm at the Minneapolis Airport, returning from a short trip, or at least what was intended as a short trip. I flew in Thursday, February 11, and made arrangements for a return trip today, February 14. Or that's what I thought I had done.
One of my cardinal rules is, if something seems wrong, it probably is. Not having bothered to check on my reservation last night, I wondered why I had not received a text message from American Airlines this morning informing me of the status of my flight. Oh well, I decided, I'll figure it out when I get to the airport. Of course, the airport was the site of my next bad indicator - the self-service check-in did not have my reservation.
I went to the counter, which was mercifully uncrowded, to discover that my return flight was scheduled not for February 14, as originally intended, but for March 14, as was CLEARLY STATED on my reservation confirmation. In other words, not only had I input my flight request incorrectly, I had failed to catch my error either on the PC screen or on my printout!
Fortunately, this story of sheer ridiculous ineptitude on my part has a happy ending. Thanks to wonderful customer service from the airline (is that an oxymoron?), not only was my error corrected, and at no cost, but my flight schedule was rearranged so that I may actually arrive back in New York much earlier than I had originally expected.
Okay, so what lessons can we draw from today's events, class? First, as Ronald Reagan said, trust, but verify. Try to look at everything with fresh eyes. It's probably impossible, and exhausting even if it were possible, but errors can creep up anywhere and anytime, and they probably do.,
Furthermore, it might actually be better to be dumb and lucky than smart. After all, if I had checked on my reservation last night and actually caught the error, I would have spent countless hours in a potentially futile effort to correct things. In this case, I was able to deal with the desk agent face-to-face - no virtual customer service here! - and it was resolved with dispatch. A final caveat however, while being dumb and lucky may occasionally work out to my benefit, I would not count on it as a strategy for life!
Of course, it's Sunday, the day traditionally set aside, by Christians at least, as a day of rest in which we do not allow worldly concerns to sully our spiritual uplift. In any case, that's my excuse and I'm sticking to it.
I'm at the Minneapolis Airport, returning from a short trip, or at least what was intended as a short trip. I flew in Thursday, February 11, and made arrangements for a return trip today, February 14. Or that's what I thought I had done.
One of my cardinal rules is, if something seems wrong, it probably is. Not having bothered to check on my reservation last night, I wondered why I had not received a text message from American Airlines this morning informing me of the status of my flight. Oh well, I decided, I'll figure it out when I get to the airport. Of course, the airport was the site of my next bad indicator - the self-service check-in did not have my reservation.
I went to the counter, which was mercifully uncrowded, to discover that my return flight was scheduled not for February 14, as originally intended, but for March 14, as was CLEARLY STATED on my reservation confirmation. In other words, not only had I input my flight request incorrectly, I had failed to catch my error either on the PC screen or on my printout!
Fortunately, this story of sheer ridiculous ineptitude on my part has a happy ending. Thanks to wonderful customer service from the airline (is that an oxymoron?), not only was my error corrected, and at no cost, but my flight schedule was rearranged so that I may actually arrive back in New York much earlier than I had originally expected.
Okay, so what lessons can we draw from today's events, class? First, as Ronald Reagan said, trust, but verify. Try to look at everything with fresh eyes. It's probably impossible, and exhausting even if it were possible, but errors can creep up anywhere and anytime, and they probably do.,
Furthermore, it might actually be better to be dumb and lucky than smart. After all, if I had checked on my reservation last night and actually caught the error, I would have spent countless hours in a potentially futile effort to correct things. In this case, I was able to deal with the desk agent face-to-face - no virtual customer service here! - and it was resolved with dispatch. A final caveat however, while being dumb and lucky may occasionally work out to my benefit, I would not count on it as a strategy for life!
Tuesday, January 26, 2010
Authors Guild Panel: E-Rights + E-books = Turmoil
The Authors Guild held an event at Scandinavia House January 18. I believe that the title was E-Rights + E-Books = Turmoil. I only know this because the person introducing the event mentioned it. There was no placard or handout announcing the event, as one usually finds at these sorts of events. I think that the emphasis was more on the substance of the discussion than the usual promotional elements. In any case, the title (as I understood it) seems to succinctly capture the tone of the evening, which gave no indication that the equation posited is anything but correct.
My notes are below, with the caveats that they are my best rendition of the discussion, with no claim to accuracy; much of the discussion has been paraphrased, rather than being a direct quote of the participants. I bring my own viewpoint and perspective to this discussion, which inevitably and inescapably influences my perception of the discussion. In other words, I am not contending that my write-up is “Fair & Balanced.”
The room looked to be able to accommodate about 200 people under normal circumstances. Given the gravity of the topic, especially to the author community, the room was filled to overflowing such that about 20 attendees were asked to sit on the stage, the steps were lined with people standing, and, I was told later, there were numerous people who were not able to get into the room at all.
This event was co-sponsored with the Association of Authors Representatives. Sidney Offit (spelling?), president of Authors Guild Foundation, opened the session. He introduced the moderator, Michael Cader (MC), of Cader Books.
The panel members were Jane Friedman (JF), CEO and Co-Founder of Open Road Integrated Media and former President and Chief Executive Officer of HarperCollins Publishers; John Sargent (JS), CEO of Macmillan; author Susan Cheever (SC) and literary agent Ira Silverberg (IS).
MC started the discussion by positing that the only problem with the session was that there were too many things to talk about. His primary intention, he said, was that the panel recognizes the need for meaningful conversation among publishers, authors & agents. We’re here to learn, not argue, he said, pointing out that this is not a tea party. (Note: two years ago, a “tea party” would have been a metaphor for a calm and civilized discussion. Now it means exactly the opposite.) MC also pointed out that the session was a public forum so that while the participants would try to be as candid as possible, they may nonetheless have constraints, especially since there are annoying people like myself taking notes and posting them publicly.
The first issue raised by MC was that the publishers’ position on E-books was not yet accepted by authors and agents.
JS began the discussion by voicing his concern that a proposal which Macmillan had sent to a small number of literary agents wound up being published in the New York Times. (Note: That seems in keeping in the moderator’s caveat about the public nature of this discussion in general.)
JS continued that the new formula was intended to get general agreement on a percentage of net proceeds of E-book revenues that would be returned by the publishers to the authors. They arrived at their preferred rate by examining their current royalty expense across all formats of printed books – trade, paperback, backlist, etc. – and found that it was 18.6% of net revenues attributable to those formats, which Macmillan then rounded up to 20%.
He admitted that he had heard that some publishers were paying up to 25% of net proceeds. Of course, antitrust law prevents him from discussing this issue outright with his nominal competitors. He recognized that Macmillan’s 20% was regarded “as less than satisfactory in the agent community.” He said that response had not convinced Macmillan to change its 20% rate in general, but that he understood that the marketplace is 25%. He also said that Macmillan would be willing to discuss the 25% royalty rate in every individual case.
He finished by arguing that the publishers agreements are better than the Google agreement. However, as he said, “We’re not at the end game, so we don’t yet know what the right number is.”
MC asked whether publishers are looking for a single rate for all varieties of E-books vs. the different rates that apply to books in different formats and at different points in their life cycles.
JS defended a single E-book rate by arguing that E-books are all a single product. Their rates are therefore different from book rates, which evolved from different formats. By the same token, however, he said that Macmillan has not negotiated any contract yet, implying that this discussion was somewhat theoretical at this point.
IS leapt into the fray. He argued that using the average royalty rate on print products is unfair, particularly given the different costs of E-book production. He also thought that an unlevel playing field was being created since JS had implied that the outcome of each negotiation depended on the clout of the particular author. Furthermore, he was concerned about locking in rates now when they could change in the future – “We‘re in transition.” He felt that since the business was being reinvented, he wanted to “play it straighter.”
JS defended the approach to negotiation by pointing out that different authors already get different contracts, including different rates, depending on their negotiating power.
IS, addressing the issue of a general rate for E-books, argued that backlist revenues could be pure profit to the publisher due to advances having been amortized and the lack of physical costs. The allocation of net proceeds for backlists was therefore different from issues regarding the frontlist revenue. Therefore, he contended, the largest share of net proceeds should go to the author.
The question arose as to whether E-books included books printed on demand, and JS affirmed that they did.
JF raised the broader issue: Do publishers have the rights for deep backlist? She felt that the issue of rights had to be addressed before the issue of royalty.
She was also concerned that it takes a long time to write a new contract, having been through that process herself. The contract developed at Random House in 1994 already referred to e-rights. Nonetheless, she felt that we are not in a transition or evolution; we’re in a revolution. It is therefore imperative to look at where the publishing community is headed. She was very concerned that, while books will continue to exist, that if the publishing industry does not embrace the digital revolution, it will be in big trouble.
MC therefore wondered about the pathway to resolution for these issues? Litigation?
JF said that she would like a friendly resolution. With regard to rights issues, they applied only to books from before 1992-1994. Afterwards, e-rights were in contracts. Nonetheless, this issue is very important to her company, Open Road, since it specializes in backlists because it wants to bring many now-neglected authors back to life.
SC felt that the question of e-rights will be settled, both in the courts and through negotiations. She felt that the broader issue is that we’re in the middle of a whirlwind that she likened to the invention of the printing press. (Note: this seems to be a common metaphor, having been raised in the discussion at last week’s Digital Breakfast as well.) She wondered whether the digital revolution will change the way we write and read. Will it change her relationship with her audience? For example, if technology allows her readers to purchase and read her books chapter by chapter, will she alter her approach to writing to do so chapter by chapter?
The discussion shifted to the respective roles of authors and publishers when MC posited that publishers look for authors to bring their audience to their work.
SC asked whether authors could now go directly to their audience without needing publisher, a role which the publisher had previously fulfilled.
JS argued that there is still a need for publishers in the digital age. He felt that they have acceded to the interests of the authors and have not exploited electronic rights unless authors want to - both frontlist and backlist. Furthermore, in the digital world, there would still be tremendous complexity involved in book publishing with regard to the multiplicity of digital platforms, DRM complexities, and so on. Furthermore, he argued that marketing would still necessary from publishers, perhaps even especially so if everyone goes directly to Amazon so as to stand out among the many choices available to readers.
JF also felt that a direct relationship between the author and their audience does not necessarily disintermediate the publisher. She took umbrage at having been called a “distributor” in an article in the New York Times. She adamantly maintained that she is a publisher, not a distributor.
She argued that the most important marketing tool for a book was word of mouth. Consequently, the biggest issue today is the ability of the publisher to market the author directly to consumers, especially in a world where consumers have short attention spans. She said that she does not want to lose a single sale. However, changes in demographics create changes in consumer behavior, and the publishing industry will have to adapt. For example, the youth audience wants books when they want it and how they want it. The publisher has to create the appropriate platform for this new environment.
SC pointed out that the author creates the thing that everyone is arguing about. Will there be a change the way people read, and by implication, the way that authors write?
IS was definitive that the reading experience will change. He cited a rendition of a David Foster Wallace novel in which the reader can click through to footnotes while in the body of the text. He also cited the Vook, which is adding audio and video components to books.
Also, publishers are important for marketing to retailers, which individual authors can not do. He therefore wants to be sure that authors are getting a fair piece of revenue, especially if authors bring new pieces or components to the equation as books evolve. He took publishers to task for not having adequately talked about the exciting components of changes in books.
What is next?
JS defended the actions of publishers by pointing out that there is a wide disparity of viewpoints among the various parties, which he compared to a complicated game of chess. He said that he is trying to get biggest piece of revenue possible for publisher/author in battle with the retail channels. He felt that, in the next 6 months, the foundations will be set for both retail prices and the publisher/author split of those prices.
In discussing developments made possible by E-books, he indicated that he was not enthusiastic about interactive video in the middle of a novel, preferring the traditional interaction between author and reader. He did concede that such functionality would be fine for DIY books such as yoga and cooking. In general, though, he was concerned about how to increase the connection between author and audience.
He also raised the concern that he is already seeing the shortening of books – as he said, he doesn’t want to see USA Today vs. New York Times. He also does not expect novels to be sold by the chapter. Authors are the creative force, so he is counting on them to come up with new ideas.
SC put it succinctly: What authors want is to get paid. If they write by the chapter, do they get paid that way?
JS felt that for non-fiction work, authors would be writing at least in chunks, as opposed to completed manuscripts. He said that overall payment would be based on net proceeds.
JF took that broad view that this is the most exciting time in publishing she could remember. The right approach was not doom and gloom; instead, it is important to assess how people will read differently. The author would remain as the brand. New formats such as the Vook would create unique opportunities. Likewise, for marketing, it is important to use all forms of multimedia and social networks. Furthermore, at Open Road, they have a “movie eye” on all projects as a way to further exploit the intellectual properties.
She felt that there should be rejoicing among authors, who will be able to write what they want to write.
Audience Question: Authors spend their lives in isolation. If they are dissatisfied with their publisher, can they leave?
JS answered that the standard answer is: it depends on the contract, which is the result of a process of negotiation. He also pointed out that electronic rights will become a bigger piece of the business. Publishers had been more flexible about exploiting electronic rights when they were less important. Now, they are a larger piece of the revenue and will be taken into account in the calculation of and considered part of the author’s advance.
JF asked rhetorically, How much are electronic rights worth? Nobody knows. She cited an example from 10 years ago, that the industry had gotten excited about the Rocket Book, but nothing happened. With the number of devices coming out, what is the audience size? How big can it be? She thinks it’s enormous and wants to share it with the author.
In dividing up the economic pie, JS pointed to the costs incurred by publishers in the E-book world. Even though they do not have printing costs for E-books, they still have overhead from traditional publishing, such as warehouses, since they have “a foot in each world.” In addition, E-books have their own infrastructure - server farms, electricity and other digital overhead.
Underlying all of this discussion is the concern that the value to consumers of an E-book is settling in between $9.99 and $12.99.
IS was not particularly sympathetic to the issue of the publishers’ costs, pointing out that when McMillan shifted from typewriters to computers, they incurred new overhead costs, which he was presumably loathe to cover out of proceeds that would otherwise have gone to his clients.
Buttressing his concern about costs, JS pointed out that trade paperbook printing only saves $1 over the costs of a hardcover book, implying that reduction in consumer value and pricing is not necessarily reflected in equivalently reduced costs.
Returning to general themes, MC was concerned that the underpinning of trust between agents and publishers is eroding. In addition, authors are concerned about diminishing advances, which is an economic issue, not particularly a trust issue
SC reiterated her earlier comment that she does not want the parties involved to worry only about their own “trenches.” She argued that everyone needs to think about everything and keep in mind the health of the entire book ecosystem.
With regard to the issue of retailers intruding into the publishers’ domain, JS argued that large retailers have already done their own publishing, so he was not threatened by the development of Amazon going directly to authors. In contrast to MC, he does not think that publishers are “at loggerheads” with agents. Further, he does not feel discussions have been antagonistic. The difference in the dialogue is his example that agents disclosed his letter to the New York Times rather than responding directly to him.
With regard to Amazon’s role in the development of the E-book marketplace, IS wants publishers to protest retail sales at low prices.
JS defended publishers from taking such actions by pointing out again that antitrust prevents publishers from discussing retail prices.
JF also pointed out that publishers have always suggested retail prices, so everyone is accustomed to an environment in which publishers can’t force retail prices.
Audience Q: what will the function be for publishers?
JS felt that the more clutter that exists, the more publishers can do for authors. The clutter reduces the “signal-to-noise” ratio, and the publisher can help an author cut through that. He viewed the publisher’s function as that of looking through the universe of manuscripts and selecting those with commercial/literary merit and promoting them. He felt that authors need the publisher’s expertise in order to convert new marketing methods - social networks, etc. - into sales.
SC’s viewpoint was that the ultimate goal of the writer is to get people to read their work, not to get it published, which is simply a means to that end. Publishers are there to help authors to do that.
JF also agreed that publishers cut through the clutter. Furthermore, there is now more clutter than ever because there are more books. For example, last year, for the first time, there were more titles that were self-published than published by traditional publishers. She also felt that there will be lots of experimentation in the book publishing industry. Book reviews don’t really exist anymore, and the blogosphere is a cluttered environment - sometimes it brings books to the public’s attention, and sometimes it doesn’t.
JS said that publishers are working on backlists, digitizing books and optimizing search for those books, but that they are focusing their resources on frontlist books.
For precisely that reason, JF wants her new company to work with traditional publishers to market the deep backlist because traditional publishers are focused on frontlist, including print copies.
IS asked whether JF’s OpenRoad was in conflict with traditional publishers?
JF replied that the relationship should not be combative. She felt that there is a lack of understanding as to what her new company does. She wants to create relationships with traditional publishers and to do their emarketing. She was hoping to establish 50/50 partnerships with publishers.
Q: What deals are being done for E-books?
JS pointed out that all contracts now include electronic rights. Royalty rates are currently based on the list price of electronic books. The formula is shifting to a net proceeds model due to changes in splits between retailer and publisher. While the rates are not yet set, in his mind, literary agents are claiming that the market rate is 25% of net proceeds.
MC pointed out that there is often ambiguity over definitions and asked for clarity on the meaning of gross vs. net.
JS defined net proceeds as gross revenue minus returns.
Q: Aside from marketing, how could publishers help exploit the interactive potential of E-books?
JS asserted that publishers view themselves as part of the creative team. He therefore viewed that is a battle for competitive advantage among book publishers since he felt that there was an uneven level of quality among the editorial staff across the industry in terms of knowledge, ability and helpfulness.
Q: What will change?
JS projected that e-book revenue, now 4% of total revenue, will grow to 7-8% next year. It will be the fastest growing segment of book revenue, but will not yet be a profit generator. He also expected to invest a lot of resources in setting up retail relationships, creating electronic infrastructure, etc., because he felt that publishers need to have the new environment figured out when E-book revenue hits 15-20% in a couple of years.
JF was more aggressive, asserting that the industry needs to figure out the appropriate split sooner, and that the process won’t take several years.
JS felt that development of the industry would be hampered by the fact that it does not yet have the basic business model in place. For example, Google is using an agency model while Amazon is a retail model.
Furthermore, he felt that much will depend on how much consumers are willing to spend on a book. If they can not get a book at a fair price, he argued that they will steal it. Therefore, he wants to protect intellectual property at as high a price as possible that will maximize sales.
JF felt that turning away any sales of ebooks is bad. It is necessary for publishers to meet consumer demands when they want the book. In return, she feels that the consumer will pay more for the book they want.
Summary: The size and participation of the audience, the quality of the panel members, and the energy of the discussion all spoke clearly to the importance of this topic to all members of the book publishing industry, and, by extension, to all of their consumers and readers. Furthermore, developments in the ebook industry are likely to have ripple effects on creators of intellectual property in all media.
The environment is quite unsettled. Can the participants wait for the evolution of the industry to calm down and indicate the direction in which it’s headed, or will the pace of change, and therefore chaos, simply accelerate? There are no answers today on which all parties can agree. Consumers will continue to generate a demand for books and other authored material, regardless of how the industry participants choose to interact with each other. How will the industry address those issues? Let’s turn the page and proceed to the next chapter.
My notes are below, with the caveats that they are my best rendition of the discussion, with no claim to accuracy; much of the discussion has been paraphrased, rather than being a direct quote of the participants. I bring my own viewpoint and perspective to this discussion, which inevitably and inescapably influences my perception of the discussion. In other words, I am not contending that my write-up is “Fair & Balanced.”
The room looked to be able to accommodate about 200 people under normal circumstances. Given the gravity of the topic, especially to the author community, the room was filled to overflowing such that about 20 attendees were asked to sit on the stage, the steps were lined with people standing, and, I was told later, there were numerous people who were not able to get into the room at all.
This event was co-sponsored with the Association of Authors Representatives. Sidney Offit (spelling?), president of Authors Guild Foundation, opened the session. He introduced the moderator, Michael Cader (MC), of Cader Books.
The panel members were Jane Friedman (JF), CEO and Co-Founder of Open Road Integrated Media and former President and Chief Executive Officer of HarperCollins Publishers; John Sargent (JS), CEO of Macmillan; author Susan Cheever (SC) and literary agent Ira Silverberg (IS).
MC started the discussion by positing that the only problem with the session was that there were too many things to talk about. His primary intention, he said, was that the panel recognizes the need for meaningful conversation among publishers, authors & agents. We’re here to learn, not argue, he said, pointing out that this is not a tea party. (Note: two years ago, a “tea party” would have been a metaphor for a calm and civilized discussion. Now it means exactly the opposite.) MC also pointed out that the session was a public forum so that while the participants would try to be as candid as possible, they may nonetheless have constraints, especially since there are annoying people like myself taking notes and posting them publicly.
The first issue raised by MC was that the publishers’ position on E-books was not yet accepted by authors and agents.
JS began the discussion by voicing his concern that a proposal which Macmillan had sent to a small number of literary agents wound up being published in the New York Times. (Note: That seems in keeping in the moderator’s caveat about the public nature of this discussion in general.)
JS continued that the new formula was intended to get general agreement on a percentage of net proceeds of E-book revenues that would be returned by the publishers to the authors. They arrived at their preferred rate by examining their current royalty expense across all formats of printed books – trade, paperback, backlist, etc. – and found that it was 18.6% of net revenues attributable to those formats, which Macmillan then rounded up to 20%.
He admitted that he had heard that some publishers were paying up to 25% of net proceeds. Of course, antitrust law prevents him from discussing this issue outright with his nominal competitors. He recognized that Macmillan’s 20% was regarded “as less than satisfactory in the agent community.” He said that response had not convinced Macmillan to change its 20% rate in general, but that he understood that the marketplace is 25%. He also said that Macmillan would be willing to discuss the 25% royalty rate in every individual case.
He finished by arguing that the publishers agreements are better than the Google agreement. However, as he said, “We’re not at the end game, so we don’t yet know what the right number is.”
MC asked whether publishers are looking for a single rate for all varieties of E-books vs. the different rates that apply to books in different formats and at different points in their life cycles.
JS defended a single E-book rate by arguing that E-books are all a single product. Their rates are therefore different from book rates, which evolved from different formats. By the same token, however, he said that Macmillan has not negotiated any contract yet, implying that this discussion was somewhat theoretical at this point.
IS leapt into the fray. He argued that using the average royalty rate on print products is unfair, particularly given the different costs of E-book production. He also thought that an unlevel playing field was being created since JS had implied that the outcome of each negotiation depended on the clout of the particular author. Furthermore, he was concerned about locking in rates now when they could change in the future – “We‘re in transition.” He felt that since the business was being reinvented, he wanted to “play it straighter.”
JS defended the approach to negotiation by pointing out that different authors already get different contracts, including different rates, depending on their negotiating power.
IS, addressing the issue of a general rate for E-books, argued that backlist revenues could be pure profit to the publisher due to advances having been amortized and the lack of physical costs. The allocation of net proceeds for backlists was therefore different from issues regarding the frontlist revenue. Therefore, he contended, the largest share of net proceeds should go to the author.
The question arose as to whether E-books included books printed on demand, and JS affirmed that they did.
JF raised the broader issue: Do publishers have the rights for deep backlist? She felt that the issue of rights had to be addressed before the issue of royalty.
She was also concerned that it takes a long time to write a new contract, having been through that process herself. The contract developed at Random House in 1994 already referred to e-rights. Nonetheless, she felt that we are not in a transition or evolution; we’re in a revolution. It is therefore imperative to look at where the publishing community is headed. She was very concerned that, while books will continue to exist, that if the publishing industry does not embrace the digital revolution, it will be in big trouble.
MC therefore wondered about the pathway to resolution for these issues? Litigation?
JF said that she would like a friendly resolution. With regard to rights issues, they applied only to books from before 1992-1994. Afterwards, e-rights were in contracts. Nonetheless, this issue is very important to her company, Open Road, since it specializes in backlists because it wants to bring many now-neglected authors back to life.
SC felt that the question of e-rights will be settled, both in the courts and through negotiations. She felt that the broader issue is that we’re in the middle of a whirlwind that she likened to the invention of the printing press. (Note: this seems to be a common metaphor, having been raised in the discussion at last week’s Digital Breakfast as well.) She wondered whether the digital revolution will change the way we write and read. Will it change her relationship with her audience? For example, if technology allows her readers to purchase and read her books chapter by chapter, will she alter her approach to writing to do so chapter by chapter?
The discussion shifted to the respective roles of authors and publishers when MC posited that publishers look for authors to bring their audience to their work.
SC asked whether authors could now go directly to their audience without needing publisher, a role which the publisher had previously fulfilled.
JS argued that there is still a need for publishers in the digital age. He felt that they have acceded to the interests of the authors and have not exploited electronic rights unless authors want to - both frontlist and backlist. Furthermore, in the digital world, there would still be tremendous complexity involved in book publishing with regard to the multiplicity of digital platforms, DRM complexities, and so on. Furthermore, he argued that marketing would still necessary from publishers, perhaps even especially so if everyone goes directly to Amazon so as to stand out among the many choices available to readers.
JF also felt that a direct relationship between the author and their audience does not necessarily disintermediate the publisher. She took umbrage at having been called a “distributor” in an article in the New York Times. She adamantly maintained that she is a publisher, not a distributor.
She argued that the most important marketing tool for a book was word of mouth. Consequently, the biggest issue today is the ability of the publisher to market the author directly to consumers, especially in a world where consumers have short attention spans. She said that she does not want to lose a single sale. However, changes in demographics create changes in consumer behavior, and the publishing industry will have to adapt. For example, the youth audience wants books when they want it and how they want it. The publisher has to create the appropriate platform for this new environment.
SC pointed out that the author creates the thing that everyone is arguing about. Will there be a change the way people read, and by implication, the way that authors write?
IS was definitive that the reading experience will change. He cited a rendition of a David Foster Wallace novel in which the reader can click through to footnotes while in the body of the text. He also cited the Vook, which is adding audio and video components to books.
Also, publishers are important for marketing to retailers, which individual authors can not do. He therefore wants to be sure that authors are getting a fair piece of revenue, especially if authors bring new pieces or components to the equation as books evolve. He took publishers to task for not having adequately talked about the exciting components of changes in books.
What is next?
JS defended the actions of publishers by pointing out that there is a wide disparity of viewpoints among the various parties, which he compared to a complicated game of chess. He said that he is trying to get biggest piece of revenue possible for publisher/author in battle with the retail channels. He felt that, in the next 6 months, the foundations will be set for both retail prices and the publisher/author split of those prices.
In discussing developments made possible by E-books, he indicated that he was not enthusiastic about interactive video in the middle of a novel, preferring the traditional interaction between author and reader. He did concede that such functionality would be fine for DIY books such as yoga and cooking. In general, though, he was concerned about how to increase the connection between author and audience.
He also raised the concern that he is already seeing the shortening of books – as he said, he doesn’t want to see USA Today vs. New York Times. He also does not expect novels to be sold by the chapter. Authors are the creative force, so he is counting on them to come up with new ideas.
SC put it succinctly: What authors want is to get paid. If they write by the chapter, do they get paid that way?
JS felt that for non-fiction work, authors would be writing at least in chunks, as opposed to completed manuscripts. He said that overall payment would be based on net proceeds.
JF took that broad view that this is the most exciting time in publishing she could remember. The right approach was not doom and gloom; instead, it is important to assess how people will read differently. The author would remain as the brand. New formats such as the Vook would create unique opportunities. Likewise, for marketing, it is important to use all forms of multimedia and social networks. Furthermore, at Open Road, they have a “movie eye” on all projects as a way to further exploit the intellectual properties.
She felt that there should be rejoicing among authors, who will be able to write what they want to write.
Audience Question: Authors spend their lives in isolation. If they are dissatisfied with their publisher, can they leave?
JS answered that the standard answer is: it depends on the contract, which is the result of a process of negotiation. He also pointed out that electronic rights will become a bigger piece of the business. Publishers had been more flexible about exploiting electronic rights when they were less important. Now, they are a larger piece of the revenue and will be taken into account in the calculation of and considered part of the author’s advance.
JF asked rhetorically, How much are electronic rights worth? Nobody knows. She cited an example from 10 years ago, that the industry had gotten excited about the Rocket Book, but nothing happened. With the number of devices coming out, what is the audience size? How big can it be? She thinks it’s enormous and wants to share it with the author.
In dividing up the economic pie, JS pointed to the costs incurred by publishers in the E-book world. Even though they do not have printing costs for E-books, they still have overhead from traditional publishing, such as warehouses, since they have “a foot in each world.” In addition, E-books have their own infrastructure - server farms, electricity and other digital overhead.
Underlying all of this discussion is the concern that the value to consumers of an E-book is settling in between $9.99 and $12.99.
IS was not particularly sympathetic to the issue of the publishers’ costs, pointing out that when McMillan shifted from typewriters to computers, they incurred new overhead costs, which he was presumably loathe to cover out of proceeds that would otherwise have gone to his clients.
Buttressing his concern about costs, JS pointed out that trade paperbook printing only saves $1 over the costs of a hardcover book, implying that reduction in consumer value and pricing is not necessarily reflected in equivalently reduced costs.
Returning to general themes, MC was concerned that the underpinning of trust between agents and publishers is eroding. In addition, authors are concerned about diminishing advances, which is an economic issue, not particularly a trust issue
SC reiterated her earlier comment that she does not want the parties involved to worry only about their own “trenches.” She argued that everyone needs to think about everything and keep in mind the health of the entire book ecosystem.
With regard to the issue of retailers intruding into the publishers’ domain, JS argued that large retailers have already done their own publishing, so he was not threatened by the development of Amazon going directly to authors. In contrast to MC, he does not think that publishers are “at loggerheads” with agents. Further, he does not feel discussions have been antagonistic. The difference in the dialogue is his example that agents disclosed his letter to the New York Times rather than responding directly to him.
With regard to Amazon’s role in the development of the E-book marketplace, IS wants publishers to protest retail sales at low prices.
JS defended publishers from taking such actions by pointing out again that antitrust prevents publishers from discussing retail prices.
JF also pointed out that publishers have always suggested retail prices, so everyone is accustomed to an environment in which publishers can’t force retail prices.
Audience Q: what will the function be for publishers?
JS felt that the more clutter that exists, the more publishers can do for authors. The clutter reduces the “signal-to-noise” ratio, and the publisher can help an author cut through that. He viewed the publisher’s function as that of looking through the universe of manuscripts and selecting those with commercial/literary merit and promoting them. He felt that authors need the publisher’s expertise in order to convert new marketing methods - social networks, etc. - into sales.
SC’s viewpoint was that the ultimate goal of the writer is to get people to read their work, not to get it published, which is simply a means to that end. Publishers are there to help authors to do that.
JF also agreed that publishers cut through the clutter. Furthermore, there is now more clutter than ever because there are more books. For example, last year, for the first time, there were more titles that were self-published than published by traditional publishers. She also felt that there will be lots of experimentation in the book publishing industry. Book reviews don’t really exist anymore, and the blogosphere is a cluttered environment - sometimes it brings books to the public’s attention, and sometimes it doesn’t.
JS said that publishers are working on backlists, digitizing books and optimizing search for those books, but that they are focusing their resources on frontlist books.
For precisely that reason, JF wants her new company to work with traditional publishers to market the deep backlist because traditional publishers are focused on frontlist, including print copies.
IS asked whether JF’s OpenRoad was in conflict with traditional publishers?
JF replied that the relationship should not be combative. She felt that there is a lack of understanding as to what her new company does. She wants to create relationships with traditional publishers and to do their emarketing. She was hoping to establish 50/50 partnerships with publishers.
Q: What deals are being done for E-books?
JS pointed out that all contracts now include electronic rights. Royalty rates are currently based on the list price of electronic books. The formula is shifting to a net proceeds model due to changes in splits between retailer and publisher. While the rates are not yet set, in his mind, literary agents are claiming that the market rate is 25% of net proceeds.
MC pointed out that there is often ambiguity over definitions and asked for clarity on the meaning of gross vs. net.
JS defined net proceeds as gross revenue minus returns.
Q: Aside from marketing, how could publishers help exploit the interactive potential of E-books?
JS asserted that publishers view themselves as part of the creative team. He therefore viewed that is a battle for competitive advantage among book publishers since he felt that there was an uneven level of quality among the editorial staff across the industry in terms of knowledge, ability and helpfulness.
Q: What will change?
JS projected that e-book revenue, now 4% of total revenue, will grow to 7-8% next year. It will be the fastest growing segment of book revenue, but will not yet be a profit generator. He also expected to invest a lot of resources in setting up retail relationships, creating electronic infrastructure, etc., because he felt that publishers need to have the new environment figured out when E-book revenue hits 15-20% in a couple of years.
JF was more aggressive, asserting that the industry needs to figure out the appropriate split sooner, and that the process won’t take several years.
JS felt that development of the industry would be hampered by the fact that it does not yet have the basic business model in place. For example, Google is using an agency model while Amazon is a retail model.
Furthermore, he felt that much will depend on how much consumers are willing to spend on a book. If they can not get a book at a fair price, he argued that they will steal it. Therefore, he wants to protect intellectual property at as high a price as possible that will maximize sales.
JF felt that turning away any sales of ebooks is bad. It is necessary for publishers to meet consumer demands when they want the book. In return, she feels that the consumer will pay more for the book they want.
Summary: The size and participation of the audience, the quality of the panel members, and the energy of the discussion all spoke clearly to the importance of this topic to all members of the book publishing industry, and, by extension, to all of their consumers and readers. Furthermore, developments in the ebook industry are likely to have ripple effects on creators of intellectual property in all media.
The environment is quite unsettled. Can the participants wait for the evolution of the industry to calm down and indicate the direction in which it’s headed, or will the pace of change, and therefore chaos, simply accelerate? There are no answers today on which all parties can agree. Consumers will continue to generate a demand for books and other authored material, regardless of how the industry participants choose to interact with each other. How will the industry address those issues? Let’s turn the page and proceed to the next chapter.
Saturday, January 23, 2010
Cheap is in the Eye of the Beholder
Lauren Weber's In Cheap We Trust is truly a book for these times. Her historical review of thrift makes it clear that we neither would be in this economic mess nor would we be condemning future generations to economic catastrophe if we had only had the clarity of mind to truly understand and maintain the virtue of thrift to which we thought we had pledged allegiance. Along with helping to shatter our historical myths about virtue, the book provides a terrific review of the state of thrift in America today - a little late, to be sure, but better than never.
Lauren's mix of personal observations, candid family anecdotes, and a wonderfully piquant writing style made me wish that she had discussed the subject for more than the thrifty 279 pages in which she covers this fascinating topic. Those wishing to see for themselves can go to: http://bit.ly/6FKCOv
Lauren's mix of personal observations, candid family anecdotes, and a wonderfully piquant writing style made me wish that she had discussed the subject for more than the thrifty 279 pages in which she covers this fascinating topic. Those wishing to see for themselves can go to: http://bit.ly/6FKCOv
Monday, January 18, 2010
Notes from the Digital Breakfast: Media Forecast 2010.
I attended the January 14 Digital Breakfast: Media Forecast 2010, moderated by Lisa Davis (LD), partner at Frankfurt Kurnit Klein & Selz, with participants Andrew Edgecliffe-Johnson (AE), media editor, Financial Times, Mike Germano (MG), president and creative director, Carrot Creative, Mike Hudak (MH), co-founder, president & CEO, blip.tv, Steven Pamon (SP), VP & head of new business development, NFL, and Reed Phillips (RP), managing partner, DeSilva + Phillips. My notes are below, with the caveats that they are my best rendition of the discussion, with no claim to accuracy; much of the discussion has been paraphrased, rather than being a direct quote of the participants; and that I bring my own viewpoint and perspective to this discussion, which influences my perception of the discussion. In other words, I am not contending that my writeup is “Fair & Balanced.”
The panel represented a variety of viewpoints about the media landscape, both as representatives of different facets of the media industry as well as some divergent points of view, as was revealed during the discussion.
LD asked each of the panelists for a quick comment.
• RP said that, while 2009 had been a very difficult year for mergers and acquisitions among media companies, he saw activity picking up as 2010 developed.
• SP pointed out that media was a growing business for the NFL, both with the NFL Network and with NFL.com.
• MH stated that blip.tv viewed itself as a next-generation television network, with 50,000 independent content producers, for whom blip.tv provides “services of scale” including distribution online and, increasingly, on television.
• MG described Carrot Creative as a new media marketing agency to whom PR and advertising agencies turn to provide new media and social networking expertise. MG said he had demonstrated the power of social media during a successful run for public office earlier this decade, powered largely by social networks.
• AE pointed out that, contrary to general trends, the Financial Times had been able to grow its circulation recently and charge for its content.
LD kicked off the discussion by asking each panel member to predict a major challenge or opportunity which they expected to materialize in 2010.
• RP said that the challenge for traditional media was in changing their business model. Traditional media players have too much staff and are mired in old processes. He predicted that they will be acquiring digital media companies in order to bring new media expertise in-house.
• SP felt that the focus of the NFL would shift from supporting advertisers to supporting consumers. Interestingly, the question of the right consumer approach would be a significant topic of discussion later this morning.
• MH argued that media is shaped by technology. He contended that CBS, for example, has not changed since it began broadcasting television in 1941. Unfortunately, and perhaps as demonstrated by that example, he felt that it has been difficult for organizations to re-orient themselves to new business models.
• MG addressed that issue by pointing out that the media needs advertisers. While traditional ad agencies have been reluctant to refocus their efforts on new media, he felt that the agencies and media will change when the advertisers demand change. The fact that advertisers are moving portions of their budgets from traditional to new media will reinforce that change.
• AE pointed out that there are many competitors for consumers’ time and attention, and therefore many opportunities for advertising. He also noted that the news is increasingly driven by social media, readers’ commentary, etc. He felt that the emerging tablet computing format was exciting, at least on a long-term basis. With a combination of an attractive device and attractive content, he felt that media companies could be able to charge consumers for their products.
LD next asked who would be the 2010 victim of a revenue decline, with print having suffered a 25% drop in 2009.
• MH felt that the near-term change would be limited. New media, while a beneficiary of a shift in ad budgets, was still a small part of the total ad budget, and would probably remain so since clients and agencies do not really know how to make best use of the new media platforms. He felt that the print business had been impacted primarily by the economy, rather than a shift of ad dollars to new media.
• SP was concerned about the NFL’s customers (advertisers) spending less due to a decline in consumer spending, i.e., reductions in total ad budgets regardless of shifting allocation among media formats. He did feel that print was suffering due to a potential long-term systemic issue that consumers do not value print content.
• MH also argued that the advent of new media causes unit prices to decline, e.g., Gutenberg’s invention of movable type probably generated greater quantities and consequently lower prices for books. He also felt that media consumption was increasing but that consumer attention is finite so that demand has some limits. The solution for content providers, he posited, was for them to bring down costs of goods sold in keeping with the lower revenue potential.
• AE returned to the issue of consumer value: are there media experiences that consumers value? He questioned whether Jay Leno was still funny or whether he was stuck in an earlier decade. He felt that the possible solution was that newspapers, for example, could be made to look better, and argued that a more competitive national market for newspapers in the United Kingdom fostered better products and consequently expanded the market for multiple newspapers. His ABCD assessment of the media landscape: Agencies are dissatisfied by the state of the advertising business; Books are caught in a struggle for allocating their value among the industry participants in an e-reader world, with Amazon seeking 70% of the revenue for its contribution to the value chain; Cable is having difficulty adapting due to its historical monopoly position having caused its competitive muscles to atrophy; and DVDs have found that the market has declined.
• SP also pointed out that movie and television studios are threatened by the decline of the DVD market, which had historically been a major driver for them. Unfortunately, much of that demand had been driven by consumers building their content libraries, and that need has now been largely fulfilled.
• RP agreed that content is under-valued and that producers have suffered as a result. He cited the example of Demand Media, which has helped devalue content by paying low prices to its content providers. He also cited technological influences, such as Eric Schmidt of Google discussing a function that would allow a consumer to upload a picture of a building and thereby receive information about that building – an example where technology would essentially replace content. He agreed that consumers have limited time resources, and felt that would drive consumers to demand quality content.
• MH argued instead that the market sets the value for content. He felt that the means of content production have been democratized via technology, and that small groups have been empowered to participate in the content marketplace. The additional supply should therefore help the market reach the appropriate price.
• SP foresaw continued disruption in the marketplace. His view was that the costs of distribution and those of marketing are inversely correlated, and that “the lines haven’t yet crossed” to provide equilibrium. In the meantime, he felt that a settled marketplace was unlikely in the near term as each sector of the industry seemed to feel free to enter other sectors, viewing such entry as “easier than it is.”
• MG took a somewhat contrary view, arguing that the value is not in the content. Instead, he felt that the user experience is key. Digital formats let people decide how they want to consume the content and how they want it to come to them. He cited MLB.com as the leader among the sports leagues an example of both providing content in new and different ways, and in standardizing the user experiences at the various team websites through centralized control.
• SP pointed out that media strategies depended on which audience each participant was trying to satisfy. Not everyone in the media food chain viewed themselves as being responsible for the consumer experience.
• MH cited the example of the NHL, which had originally allowed each team to manage its own website but eventually moved to the centralized model under the control of the league, presumably to improve the consumer experience and make it more consistent.
• SP argued that the NFL focused its efforts where it felt the core consumer experience was most critical. For example, he cited the NFL Sunday Ticket program as a successful consumer service and said that the NFL would develop additional products and services as they perceived the development of consumer interest and demand. In keeping with his theme of selective innovation, he also argued that “Just because you can, doesn’t mean you should.” He brought up the example of ESPN, which tried developing new consumer experiences, such as ESPN Mobile, not all of which have been successful.
• AE projected that media companies would have to decide whether they have or can develop the necessary expertise and make the necessary investments in new media. If they cannot, they probably need to find partners.
• MH pointed out a distinction between west coast and east coast startups. He felt that the former viewed technology as the intended end or objective of the business. He argued that New York companies generally consider the user experience and value to be the key. Citing blip.tv, he said the company thinks of itself as a media company that is using technology, not as a technology company per se.
• MG thinks that the future of media companies will be subject to a generational shift with a greater comfort and facility with new media exhibited by the new generation. In addition, lower capital and other barriers to entry will enable more innovation, with consumers investing their time and attention into the most innovative companies.
LD finished the discussion portion by asking each of the participants for 3 predictions.
• AE expected more business failures to come as numerous weakened companies succumb to economic and other pressures. He also did not expect the tablet to become a mass-market product this year.
• RP predicted more M&A activity. In addition to the acquisition of digital companies by mainstream media, which he had mentioned earlier, he also foresaw consolidation among digital companies themselves.
• MG expected more business partnerships. In addition, he said that there would be significant cultural changes in the workplace environment in order to address the needs and desires of new media employees and to foster additional innovation.
• SP felt that 2010 would be the last year of the PC as the dominant consumer computing device, supplanted by laptops, phones and other powerful and more portable form factors.
• MH agreed that the PC would diminish in importance. He also pointed to the rise of televisions as part of the online experience, with the top 5 television manufacturers having models with Ethernet connectivity. That would also foster “over-the-top” consumer viewing of video from online sources instead of from cable or satellite providers.
• SP pointed out that the shift in video sourcing from cable/satellite to online would depend primarily on the valuation proposition for the consumer.
• MH felt that, in keeping with previous industry developments, independent OTT boxes such as Roku and Boxee would have their functionality eventually incorporated into the cable/satellite set-top boxes, much as at happened with Tivo and DVRs.
A question was raised from the audience – in a world with so much content from so many sources, what will serve as quality filters?
• MG felt that one’s friends would serve that function via social intersections such as the social networking sites. To validate these user-generated filters, users could make their preferences and friends public.
• MH predicted a network of filters, such as Tumblr, which seems to have supplanted the New York Times and Drudge for his news consumption.
Another question was about the opportunity for the monetization of websites in a world of disaggregated audiences.
• MH said that blip.tv is able to host shows with small audiences since they have essentially unlimited video inventory. The company provides these shows with monetization of their audiences by bundling the shows and creating scale for advertisers, in addition to targeting, which increases the value of even small audiences. He cited such aggregation in other media areas, such as regional networks of publishers.
All in all, it was a lively, engaging discussion. 2010 will both prove and disprove many of these predictions, but the most interesting events will be those that no one foresaw.
The panel represented a variety of viewpoints about the media landscape, both as representatives of different facets of the media industry as well as some divergent points of view, as was revealed during the discussion.
LD asked each of the panelists for a quick comment.
• RP said that, while 2009 had been a very difficult year for mergers and acquisitions among media companies, he saw activity picking up as 2010 developed.
• SP pointed out that media was a growing business for the NFL, both with the NFL Network and with NFL.com.
• MH stated that blip.tv viewed itself as a next-generation television network, with 50,000 independent content producers, for whom blip.tv provides “services of scale” including distribution online and, increasingly, on television.
• MG described Carrot Creative as a new media marketing agency to whom PR and advertising agencies turn to provide new media and social networking expertise. MG said he had demonstrated the power of social media during a successful run for public office earlier this decade, powered largely by social networks.
• AE pointed out that, contrary to general trends, the Financial Times had been able to grow its circulation recently and charge for its content.
LD kicked off the discussion by asking each panel member to predict a major challenge or opportunity which they expected to materialize in 2010.
• RP said that the challenge for traditional media was in changing their business model. Traditional media players have too much staff and are mired in old processes. He predicted that they will be acquiring digital media companies in order to bring new media expertise in-house.
• SP felt that the focus of the NFL would shift from supporting advertisers to supporting consumers. Interestingly, the question of the right consumer approach would be a significant topic of discussion later this morning.
• MH argued that media is shaped by technology. He contended that CBS, for example, has not changed since it began broadcasting television in 1941. Unfortunately, and perhaps as demonstrated by that example, he felt that it has been difficult for organizations to re-orient themselves to new business models.
• MG addressed that issue by pointing out that the media needs advertisers. While traditional ad agencies have been reluctant to refocus their efforts on new media, he felt that the agencies and media will change when the advertisers demand change. The fact that advertisers are moving portions of their budgets from traditional to new media will reinforce that change.
• AE pointed out that there are many competitors for consumers’ time and attention, and therefore many opportunities for advertising. He also noted that the news is increasingly driven by social media, readers’ commentary, etc. He felt that the emerging tablet computing format was exciting, at least on a long-term basis. With a combination of an attractive device and attractive content, he felt that media companies could be able to charge consumers for their products.
LD next asked who would be the 2010 victim of a revenue decline, with print having suffered a 25% drop in 2009.
• MH felt that the near-term change would be limited. New media, while a beneficiary of a shift in ad budgets, was still a small part of the total ad budget, and would probably remain so since clients and agencies do not really know how to make best use of the new media platforms. He felt that the print business had been impacted primarily by the economy, rather than a shift of ad dollars to new media.
• SP was concerned about the NFL’s customers (advertisers) spending less due to a decline in consumer spending, i.e., reductions in total ad budgets regardless of shifting allocation among media formats. He did feel that print was suffering due to a potential long-term systemic issue that consumers do not value print content.
• MH also argued that the advent of new media causes unit prices to decline, e.g., Gutenberg’s invention of movable type probably generated greater quantities and consequently lower prices for books. He also felt that media consumption was increasing but that consumer attention is finite so that demand has some limits. The solution for content providers, he posited, was for them to bring down costs of goods sold in keeping with the lower revenue potential.
• AE returned to the issue of consumer value: are there media experiences that consumers value? He questioned whether Jay Leno was still funny or whether he was stuck in an earlier decade. He felt that the possible solution was that newspapers, for example, could be made to look better, and argued that a more competitive national market for newspapers in the United Kingdom fostered better products and consequently expanded the market for multiple newspapers. His ABCD assessment of the media landscape: Agencies are dissatisfied by the state of the advertising business; Books are caught in a struggle for allocating their value among the industry participants in an e-reader world, with Amazon seeking 70% of the revenue for its contribution to the value chain; Cable is having difficulty adapting due to its historical monopoly position having caused its competitive muscles to atrophy; and DVDs have found that the market has declined.
• SP also pointed out that movie and television studios are threatened by the decline of the DVD market, which had historically been a major driver for them. Unfortunately, much of that demand had been driven by consumers building their content libraries, and that need has now been largely fulfilled.
• RP agreed that content is under-valued and that producers have suffered as a result. He cited the example of Demand Media, which has helped devalue content by paying low prices to its content providers. He also cited technological influences, such as Eric Schmidt of Google discussing a function that would allow a consumer to upload a picture of a building and thereby receive information about that building – an example where technology would essentially replace content. He agreed that consumers have limited time resources, and felt that would drive consumers to demand quality content.
• MH argued instead that the market sets the value for content. He felt that the means of content production have been democratized via technology, and that small groups have been empowered to participate in the content marketplace. The additional supply should therefore help the market reach the appropriate price.
• SP foresaw continued disruption in the marketplace. His view was that the costs of distribution and those of marketing are inversely correlated, and that “the lines haven’t yet crossed” to provide equilibrium. In the meantime, he felt that a settled marketplace was unlikely in the near term as each sector of the industry seemed to feel free to enter other sectors, viewing such entry as “easier than it is.”
• MG took a somewhat contrary view, arguing that the value is not in the content. Instead, he felt that the user experience is key. Digital formats let people decide how they want to consume the content and how they want it to come to them. He cited MLB.com as the leader among the sports leagues an example of both providing content in new and different ways, and in standardizing the user experiences at the various team websites through centralized control.
• SP pointed out that media strategies depended on which audience each participant was trying to satisfy. Not everyone in the media food chain viewed themselves as being responsible for the consumer experience.
• MH cited the example of the NHL, which had originally allowed each team to manage its own website but eventually moved to the centralized model under the control of the league, presumably to improve the consumer experience and make it more consistent.
• SP argued that the NFL focused its efforts where it felt the core consumer experience was most critical. For example, he cited the NFL Sunday Ticket program as a successful consumer service and said that the NFL would develop additional products and services as they perceived the development of consumer interest and demand. In keeping with his theme of selective innovation, he also argued that “Just because you can, doesn’t mean you should.” He brought up the example of ESPN, which tried developing new consumer experiences, such as ESPN Mobile, not all of which have been successful.
• AE projected that media companies would have to decide whether they have or can develop the necessary expertise and make the necessary investments in new media. If they cannot, they probably need to find partners.
• MH pointed out a distinction between west coast and east coast startups. He felt that the former viewed technology as the intended end or objective of the business. He argued that New York companies generally consider the user experience and value to be the key. Citing blip.tv, he said the company thinks of itself as a media company that is using technology, not as a technology company per se.
• MG thinks that the future of media companies will be subject to a generational shift with a greater comfort and facility with new media exhibited by the new generation. In addition, lower capital and other barriers to entry will enable more innovation, with consumers investing their time and attention into the most innovative companies.
LD finished the discussion portion by asking each of the participants for 3 predictions.
• AE expected more business failures to come as numerous weakened companies succumb to economic and other pressures. He also did not expect the tablet to become a mass-market product this year.
• RP predicted more M&A activity. In addition to the acquisition of digital companies by mainstream media, which he had mentioned earlier, he also foresaw consolidation among digital companies themselves.
• MG expected more business partnerships. In addition, he said that there would be significant cultural changes in the workplace environment in order to address the needs and desires of new media employees and to foster additional innovation.
• SP felt that 2010 would be the last year of the PC as the dominant consumer computing device, supplanted by laptops, phones and other powerful and more portable form factors.
• MH agreed that the PC would diminish in importance. He also pointed to the rise of televisions as part of the online experience, with the top 5 television manufacturers having models with Ethernet connectivity. That would also foster “over-the-top” consumer viewing of video from online sources instead of from cable or satellite providers.
• SP pointed out that the shift in video sourcing from cable/satellite to online would depend primarily on the valuation proposition for the consumer.
• MH felt that, in keeping with previous industry developments, independent OTT boxes such as Roku and Boxee would have their functionality eventually incorporated into the cable/satellite set-top boxes, much as at happened with Tivo and DVRs.
A question was raised from the audience – in a world with so much content from so many sources, what will serve as quality filters?
• MG felt that one’s friends would serve that function via social intersections such as the social networking sites. To validate these user-generated filters, users could make their preferences and friends public.
• MH predicted a network of filters, such as Tumblr, which seems to have supplanted the New York Times and Drudge for his news consumption.
Another question was about the opportunity for the monetization of websites in a world of disaggregated audiences.
• MH said that blip.tv is able to host shows with small audiences since they have essentially unlimited video inventory. The company provides these shows with monetization of their audiences by bundling the shows and creating scale for advertisers, in addition to targeting, which increases the value of even small audiences. He cited such aggregation in other media areas, such as regional networks of publishers.
All in all, it was a lively, engaging discussion. 2010 will both prove and disprove many of these predictions, but the most interesting events will be those that no one foresaw.
Labels:
digital breakfast,
media,
online
Wednesday, January 06, 2010
Trying to Help the Environment, But with Unintended Consequences?
One of the wasteful and environmentally harmful everyday items is the disposable plastic grocery bag. I completely understand and agree that it is a wasteful use of scarce resources, that they last forever whether in a landfill or disposed of in an even less environmentally-sensitive way, and that it is dangerous to wildlife.
One solution that has been bruited about, and with which we often try to comply, is the non-disposable, reusable grocery bag. My only concern is that this solution has the potential to make things worse, not better. The primary issue is that the reusable bag itself is a consumer of many of the same resources that would otherwise go into making the disposable bags, and it certainly requires significantly more resources than the disposable bags.
Question #1 therefore is: how many times must a reusable bag be used instead of a disposable bag in order to break-even from a resource point of view, i.e., that the resources consumed from manufacturing one reusable bag is equal to or less than those consumed from the manufacture of the disposable bag it replaces? If, for example, a reusable bag requires 20 times the manufacturing resources as a disposable bag, then it needs to be used at least 20 times in order to have benefited the environment, manufacturing-wise.
If the bags, on average, are being used to that extent, that would be terrific, both for the environment and for helping change our mindset toward reuse instead of disposal. If, as I fear, that is not happening, then our good intentions of assisting the environment are resulting in negative consequences as we are causing net harm to the environment through the manufacture of the reusable (but insufficiently-used) grocery bags.
If that is indeed the case, that brings us to Question #2, which is: could we achieve much of the originally-desired objective simply by reusing the disposable bags. Granted, these bags have a much shorter life than the reusable bags, being less sturdy and more prone to ripping, tearing, etc. On the other hand, if we can reduce the usage of these bags by reusing otherwise disposable items, we can still provide a benefit to the environment.
Alternatively, we can mandate the use of reusable bags and prohibit the use of disposable bags, which some local governments have apparently done. That’s a good step, but I would certainly prefer to see a bottoms-up groundswell from the populace than a top-down imposed solution. After all, since the problem belongs to all of us, so should the solution. It’s similar to the reduction in smoking – I believe that the general societal disapproval of smoking has done more to reduce its incidence than the various legislative prohibitions, which seem to be following the public mood rather than leading it. Let’s take that approach here as well.
One solution that has been bruited about, and with which we often try to comply, is the non-disposable, reusable grocery bag. My only concern is that this solution has the potential to make things worse, not better. The primary issue is that the reusable bag itself is a consumer of many of the same resources that would otherwise go into making the disposable bags, and it certainly requires significantly more resources than the disposable bags.
Question #1 therefore is: how many times must a reusable bag be used instead of a disposable bag in order to break-even from a resource point of view, i.e., that the resources consumed from manufacturing one reusable bag is equal to or less than those consumed from the manufacture of the disposable bag it replaces? If, for example, a reusable bag requires 20 times the manufacturing resources as a disposable bag, then it needs to be used at least 20 times in order to have benefited the environment, manufacturing-wise.
If the bags, on average, are being used to that extent, that would be terrific, both for the environment and for helping change our mindset toward reuse instead of disposal. If, as I fear, that is not happening, then our good intentions of assisting the environment are resulting in negative consequences as we are causing net harm to the environment through the manufacture of the reusable (but insufficiently-used) grocery bags.
If that is indeed the case, that brings us to Question #2, which is: could we achieve much of the originally-desired objective simply by reusing the disposable bags. Granted, these bags have a much shorter life than the reusable bags, being less sturdy and more prone to ripping, tearing, etc. On the other hand, if we can reduce the usage of these bags by reusing otherwise disposable items, we can still provide a benefit to the environment.
Alternatively, we can mandate the use of reusable bags and prohibit the use of disposable bags, which some local governments have apparently done. That’s a good step, but I would certainly prefer to see a bottoms-up groundswell from the populace than a top-down imposed solution. After all, since the problem belongs to all of us, so should the solution. It’s similar to the reduction in smoking – I believe that the general societal disapproval of smoking has done more to reduce its incidence than the various legislative prohibitions, which seem to be following the public mood rather than leading it. Let’s take that approach here as well.
Monday, December 21, 2009
Top 10 for 2010 ...
What will be the top 10 events of 2010? Give us your predictions!
1. The most expected political event of 2010 - passage of health care reform?
2. The most unexpected political event of 2010 - the failure to pass health care reform?
3. The next disruptive technology to follow Twitter and Facebook?
4. The biggest media deal of 2010?
5. The most important media deal of 2010?
6. The most unlikely media event of 2010, to parallel the Tiger Woods scandal of 2009?
7. The closing price for the Dow Jones Average at the end of 2010?
8. The biggest movie of 2010?
9. The most unlikely media celebrity of 2010?
10. The most unlikely political celebrity of 2010 (is that the same as #9, see Sarah Palin)?
1. The most expected political event of 2010 - passage of health care reform?
2. The most unexpected political event of 2010 - the failure to pass health care reform?
3. The next disruptive technology to follow Twitter and Facebook?
4. The biggest media deal of 2010?
5. The most important media deal of 2010?
6. The most unlikely media event of 2010, to parallel the Tiger Woods scandal of 2009?
7. The closing price for the Dow Jones Average at the end of 2010?
8. The biggest movie of 2010?
9. The most unlikely media celebrity of 2010?
10. The most unlikely political celebrity of 2010 (is that the same as #9, see Sarah Palin)?
Sunday, December 13, 2009
Scheduled to Testify at the NYC Council Committee on Tech. about the Importance of Tech Companies to the City
I am scheduled to testify at the hearing to be held on Wednesday, December 16, by the New York City Council Committee on Technology in Government. The Committee is seeking suggestions from the tech and business community as to how City government can foster the development of small technology start-ups. In turn, I am seeking suggestions from each of you.
My initial thoughts are that there are 3 key areas of development:
• Ease of creation of new companies. In the last few months, I have met with a lot of new companies and with budding entrepreneurs who want to start new companies, both because they have great new ideas or out of economic necessity. Anything that City government can do to make it easier to create new companies, especially in areas such as licensing, permitting and incorporating, will encourage more people to take the plunge.
• Increased employment opportunities. Many of these companies are one-person operations. They could definitely use more help, but hiring people is often a risky proposition. Anything that the City can do to make it easier to create in-house staff will create jobs. This is especially valuable because we want to encourage entrepreneurs to create new jobs, especially since their alternative is often to out-source functions, which pushes the work, and jobs, to other locations here in the U.S. or abroad. Furthermore, in-house development of technology is important to these fledgling companies so that they can have greater control over their technology and more flexibility with regard to its development.
• Support services. Every startup technology company needs an ecosystem of vendors and suppliers to enable its business – hosting, legal, accounting, advertising, etc. Making it easy for entrepreneurs to launch new technology companies will have spin-off benefits within the ecosystem of companies and agencies that spring up or staff up to service these new clients.
I am open to additional suggestions from the tech, entrepreneur and finance communities as to other items that any of you feel should be raised in this forum. Hopefully, the benefits of this inquiry by the City government will result in benefits to us all.
More information about the hearing is available here: http://bit.ly/8gg59b and the media alert is reproduced below:
Who: Council Committee on Technology in Government, Council Committee on Small Business, Technology Community, Entrepreneurs, and Developers
When: Wednesday, December 16, 2009 at 10 AM
What: Public Hearing on Tech start-ups, their benefits to NYC, and methods to encourage digital entrepreneurship
Where: Council Chambers, City Hall
(The Hearing will be webcasted through www.livestream.com/nycctechcomm and tweeted on www.twitter.com/nycctechcomm. More details below.)
New York, NY - On Wednesday, December 16, 2009 at 10 AM in the Council Chambers of City Hall, the New York City Council Committees on Technology in Government and Small Business will hold a joint public hearing to examine how small technology start-ups are surviving in this tough economy. This hearing will help the Council understand the dynamics behind successful firms as well as what options are available to the City in aiding these important businesses in their struggle to remain competitive and viable in a global environment.
City lawmakers are seeking ways to foster small business growth and boost New York City’s image as technology and digital media leader. Small businesses and information technology groups offer a myriad of job opportunities and ideas to the broader economy. Current incubators, venture capitalist funds, and industry consortiums help improve the economy and provide support for future entrepreneurs. By understanding the dynamics of how these firms operate, the City can help facilitate broader innovation and attract additional companies within knowledge-based industries.
The Committee on Technology in Government will be live twittering and webcasting this entire public hearing.
* You can follow us on twitter at www.twitter.com/nycctechcomm and use the tag #nycstartup if you have any comments, suggestions, and questions during the hearing. Wireless Internet is available to attendees to tweet this hearing.
* If you are unable to attend the hearing, you can view the live webcast at www.livestream.com/nycctechcomm. You may also use the chat function available on the site for comments, questions and suggestions.
* Furthermore, you can follow all of the Tech Committee’s activities on www.nycctechcomm.wordpress.com.
My initial thoughts are that there are 3 key areas of development:
• Ease of creation of new companies. In the last few months, I have met with a lot of new companies and with budding entrepreneurs who want to start new companies, both because they have great new ideas or out of economic necessity. Anything that City government can do to make it easier to create new companies, especially in areas such as licensing, permitting and incorporating, will encourage more people to take the plunge.
• Increased employment opportunities. Many of these companies are one-person operations. They could definitely use more help, but hiring people is often a risky proposition. Anything that the City can do to make it easier to create in-house staff will create jobs. This is especially valuable because we want to encourage entrepreneurs to create new jobs, especially since their alternative is often to out-source functions, which pushes the work, and jobs, to other locations here in the U.S. or abroad. Furthermore, in-house development of technology is important to these fledgling companies so that they can have greater control over their technology and more flexibility with regard to its development.
• Support services. Every startup technology company needs an ecosystem of vendors and suppliers to enable its business – hosting, legal, accounting, advertising, etc. Making it easy for entrepreneurs to launch new technology companies will have spin-off benefits within the ecosystem of companies and agencies that spring up or staff up to service these new clients.
I am open to additional suggestions from the tech, entrepreneur and finance communities as to other items that any of you feel should be raised in this forum. Hopefully, the benefits of this inquiry by the City government will result in benefits to us all.
More information about the hearing is available here: http://bit.ly/8gg59b and the media alert is reproduced below:
Who: Council Committee on Technology in Government, Council Committee on Small Business, Technology Community, Entrepreneurs, and Developers
When: Wednesday, December 16, 2009 at 10 AM
What: Public Hearing on Tech start-ups, their benefits to NYC, and methods to encourage digital entrepreneurship
Where: Council Chambers, City Hall
(The Hearing will be webcasted through www.livestream.com/nycctechcomm and tweeted on www.twitter.com/nycctechcomm. More details below.)
New York, NY - On Wednesday, December 16, 2009 at 10 AM in the Council Chambers of City Hall, the New York City Council Committees on Technology in Government and Small Business will hold a joint public hearing to examine how small technology start-ups are surviving in this tough economy. This hearing will help the Council understand the dynamics behind successful firms as well as what options are available to the City in aiding these important businesses in their struggle to remain competitive and viable in a global environment.
City lawmakers are seeking ways to foster small business growth and boost New York City’s image as technology and digital media leader. Small businesses and information technology groups offer a myriad of job opportunities and ideas to the broader economy. Current incubators, venture capitalist funds, and industry consortiums help improve the economy and provide support for future entrepreneurs. By understanding the dynamics of how these firms operate, the City can help facilitate broader innovation and attract additional companies within knowledge-based industries.
The Committee on Technology in Government will be live twittering and webcasting this entire public hearing.
* You can follow us on twitter at www.twitter.com/nycctechcomm and use the tag #nycstartup if you have any comments, suggestions, and questions during the hearing. Wireless Internet is available to attendees to tweet this hearing.
* If you are unable to attend the hearing, you can view the live webcast at www.livestream.com/nycctechcomm. You may also use the chat function available on the site for comments, questions and suggestions.
* Furthermore, you can follow all of the Tech Committee’s activities on www.nycctechcomm.wordpress.com.
Labels:
entrepreneurs,
startups,
technology
Thursday, September 10, 2009
Studio One Networks Launches Venture Capital Operation
STUDIO ONE NETWORKS LAUNCHES VENTURE CAPITAL OPERATION
Unique venture program will provide exposure for innovative content and media technology firms, and assist creators of groundbreaking programming and interactive services for the Internet and beyond.
NEW YORK, September 10, 2009 – Further strengthening its position as the leading Internet content syndication service worldwide by meeting the diverse needs of its rapidly expanding user base, Studio One Networks announced the launch of Studio One Networks Ventures, which will make equity investments in media and technology companies in exchange for inclusion and promotion in the award-winning programming of Studio One Networks.
Studio One Networks Ventures is unique in the marketplace because it serves as a content development studio, a network platform, and a venture capital program for entrepreneurs, start-up companies and independent innovators in the creation of groundbreaking interactive content and technology solutions. The Ventures division will focus on the delivery of new services, enhancement of existing products, entry or expansion into key strategic marketing and critical research and development activities. Selected companies will have access to Studio One’s market-leading syndication network and its 120 million monthly unique users. In return, Studio One Networks Ventures will receive an equity position in these companies, enabling it to share in their future success.
Andrew Susman, CEO of Studio One Networks, said, “This program will help ensure that we continuously re-define ‘state of the art’ in content and content enhancements. We developed Ventures to identify and provide an accelerator effect for entrepreneurs who are developing content and technologies that take advantage of the vast possibilities of the Internet and serve the needs of our audiences, media partners and supporting sponsors.
“The formation of Ventures also demonstrates Studio One’s commitment to the innovation community, which we’ve been a part of for more than a decade,” Mr. Susman continued. “We all remember people who believed in us early on and gave us an opportunity. We want Studio One Ventures to be that kind of entity.”
The Managing Director of Studio One Networks Ventures is Victor Lee, who was previously Director of Capital Cities Capital, a venture capital operation that invested in media and technology companies in exchange for providing access to the media assets of Capital Cities/ABC. Mr. Lee was also previously President of U.S. Broadcast Services for Medialink Worldwide, a leading broadcast public relations firm, and President of Brandstands International, a digital out-of-home video network.
Mr. Susman added, “Victor has the perfect background in finance and media to run this operation for us, based on his experience with a very similar program at Capital Cities Capital, as a private equity investor at the IBM pension fund and as head of strategic planning at Time Inc.”
About Studio One Networks
Established in 1998, Studio One Networks pioneered the discipline of Internet content syndication for megabrands and major media partners. Today, Studio One is the oldest, largest and most successful firm in the field. Studio One has amassed a loyal group of exclusive sponsors. Their programs include Iams (The Dog Daily), Symantec (Your Security Resource) and Bridgestone (Driving Today). Every day, Studio One reaches more than 112 million viewers globally through 500 syndication partners in 14 languages.
Unique venture program will provide exposure for innovative content and media technology firms, and assist creators of groundbreaking programming and interactive services for the Internet and beyond.
NEW YORK, September 10, 2009 – Further strengthening its position as the leading Internet content syndication service worldwide by meeting the diverse needs of its rapidly expanding user base, Studio One Networks announced the launch of Studio One Networks Ventures, which will make equity investments in media and technology companies in exchange for inclusion and promotion in the award-winning programming of Studio One Networks.
Studio One Networks Ventures is unique in the marketplace because it serves as a content development studio, a network platform, and a venture capital program for entrepreneurs, start-up companies and independent innovators in the creation of groundbreaking interactive content and technology solutions. The Ventures division will focus on the delivery of new services, enhancement of existing products, entry or expansion into key strategic marketing and critical research and development activities. Selected companies will have access to Studio One’s market-leading syndication network and its 120 million monthly unique users. In return, Studio One Networks Ventures will receive an equity position in these companies, enabling it to share in their future success.
Andrew Susman, CEO of Studio One Networks, said, “This program will help ensure that we continuously re-define ‘state of the art’ in content and content enhancements. We developed Ventures to identify and provide an accelerator effect for entrepreneurs who are developing content and technologies that take advantage of the vast possibilities of the Internet and serve the needs of our audiences, media partners and supporting sponsors.
“The formation of Ventures also demonstrates Studio One’s commitment to the innovation community, which we’ve been a part of for more than a decade,” Mr. Susman continued. “We all remember people who believed in us early on and gave us an opportunity. We want Studio One Ventures to be that kind of entity.”
The Managing Director of Studio One Networks Ventures is Victor Lee, who was previously Director of Capital Cities Capital, a venture capital operation that invested in media and technology companies in exchange for providing access to the media assets of Capital Cities/ABC. Mr. Lee was also previously President of U.S. Broadcast Services for Medialink Worldwide, a leading broadcast public relations firm, and President of Brandstands International, a digital out-of-home video network.
Mr. Susman added, “Victor has the perfect background in finance and media to run this operation for us, based on his experience with a very similar program at Capital Cities Capital, as a private equity investor at the IBM pension fund and as head of strategic planning at Time Inc.”
About Studio One Networks
Established in 1998, Studio One Networks pioneered the discipline of Internet content syndication for megabrands and major media partners. Today, Studio One is the oldest, largest and most successful firm in the field. Studio One has amassed a loyal group of exclusive sponsors. Their programs include Iams (The Dog Daily), Symantec (Your Security Resource) and Bridgestone (Driving Today). Every day, Studio One reaches more than 112 million viewers globally through 500 syndication partners in 14 languages.
Monday, August 10, 2009
Julie & Julia: It's Not About the Food, It's About the Media
"Julie & Julia" opened this weekend, a movie about Julia Child's rise as one of America's premier food mavens and a blogger's search for the meaning of life through the re-creation of each of the 540-some recipes in Julia's seminal tome, "Mastering the Art of French Cooking."
The two principals never meet, and the movie cuts back forth between their stories. Among the interesting contrasts between the two tales - in addition to period costumes and heavy (cigarette) smoking during Julia's time, especially during dinner time - is the stark difference in media and the opportunity for self-expression. For example, Julia and her co-conspirators set out to write the first cookbook explaining French cooking in English for the American housewife audience. That entails laboriously typing over 700 pages of manuscripts, with copies possible only through the use of carbon paper and onion-skin duplicates. The completed book must then be (snail) mailed to a publisher, who stands as the gatekeeper between the authors and their audience. The first prospective publisher rejects the book, but the second comes to the rescue. This gives Julia's book a much smoother ride to publication than that endured by many of today's most well-known authors, including J.K. Rowling and John Grisham, who apparently encountered double-digit rejections before reaching publication.
By contrast, Julie Powell, the intrepid blogger, has no such third-party obstacles. She is online within minutes (at least in movie time) of conceiving the idea of her blog. Of course, finding an audience (other than her mother) takes a little longer, but at least the audience (and media attention) she attracts is presumably a function of the quality of her writing, not dependent on the judging panel of a publisher that makes the American Idol crew seem promiscuous.
The moral of the story seems to be that, in this web 2.0, interconnected, user-generated world, anyone can be a writer. As one would expect, in that event, anyone will. Even me.
The two principals never meet, and the movie cuts back forth between their stories. Among the interesting contrasts between the two tales - in addition to period costumes and heavy (cigarette) smoking during Julia's time, especially during dinner time - is the stark difference in media and the opportunity for self-expression. For example, Julia and her co-conspirators set out to write the first cookbook explaining French cooking in English for the American housewife audience. That entails laboriously typing over 700 pages of manuscripts, with copies possible only through the use of carbon paper and onion-skin duplicates. The completed book must then be (snail) mailed to a publisher, who stands as the gatekeeper between the authors and their audience. The first prospective publisher rejects the book, but the second comes to the rescue. This gives Julia's book a much smoother ride to publication than that endured by many of today's most well-known authors, including J.K. Rowling and John Grisham, who apparently encountered double-digit rejections before reaching publication.
By contrast, Julie Powell, the intrepid blogger, has no such third-party obstacles. She is online within minutes (at least in movie time) of conceiving the idea of her blog. Of course, finding an audience (other than her mother) takes a little longer, but at least the audience (and media attention) she attracts is presumably a function of the quality of her writing, not dependent on the judging panel of a publisher that makes the American Idol crew seem promiscuous.
The moral of the story seems to be that, in this web 2.0, interconnected, user-generated world, anyone can be a writer. As one would expect, in that event, anyone will. Even me.
Labels:
blogs,
Julie and Julia,
media,
web 2.0
Monday, July 13, 2009
Nothing Is Truly Free - You Always End Up Paying Something
I was reading the New York Times review of Chris Anderson's new book, "Free." The reviewer was Virginia Postrel, and her review certainly made the book sound very interesting. My interest was particularly piqued when she mentioned that the book was available free online until its publication date. Ms. Postrel pointed out that this "free" distribution of the book went to the book's core thesis, that one can create a lucrative business by giving away products so as to create demand for non-free products and services. Being the cheapskate that I am, I decided to check this out here on Scribd.
Immediately it became apparent that there are a few impediments to enjoying this book "freely," to coin a phrase. Let's start with its unavailability beyond the pub date. Okay, I thought, why don't I just download the book at read it as my leisure? No good - download function is disabled.
Alternatively, why don't I just print it out in a pdf? Oops, that's been disabled as well.
As a result, I am limited to reading the book in the Scribd reader. Given the ravages of age and its impact on my eyesight, I needed to enlarge the text, which no longer fit comfortably within the reader, such that each pair of adjoining pages could be read only by scrolling laterally and horizontally (If anyone knows of a way to ameliorate this, please let me know.).
While the content is "free," the time, effort and aggravation required for me to read the book in this format is a much higher "cost" than I am willing to bear. After all, the book is over 250 pages in length - that equates to 125 pairs of pages. Perhaps this too was part of the business plan - the book is nominally free, but it's so inconvenient to read that I'll be compelled to buy it instead. If so, it seems to have backfired. I'm now so annoyed at having been essentially "suckered" into thinking I was getting to read a book for free, that I'm just going to get it for free, for real, at my library. So there!
Immediately it became apparent that there are a few impediments to enjoying this book "freely," to coin a phrase. Let's start with its unavailability beyond the pub date. Okay, I thought, why don't I just download the book at read it as my leisure? No good - download function is disabled.
Alternatively, why don't I just print it out in a pdf? Oops, that's been disabled as well.
As a result, I am limited to reading the book in the Scribd reader. Given the ravages of age and its impact on my eyesight, I needed to enlarge the text, which no longer fit comfortably within the reader, such that each pair of adjoining pages could be read only by scrolling laterally and horizontally (If anyone knows of a way to ameliorate this, please let me know.).
While the content is "free," the time, effort and aggravation required for me to read the book in this format is a much higher "cost" than I am willing to bear. After all, the book is over 250 pages in length - that equates to 125 pairs of pages. Perhaps this too was part of the business plan - the book is nominally free, but it's so inconvenient to read that I'll be compelled to buy it instead. If so, it seems to have backfired. I'm now so annoyed at having been essentially "suckered" into thinking I was getting to read a book for free, that I'm just going to get it for free, for real, at my library. So there!
Sunday, July 12, 2009
Are Online Videos Getting Shorter or Longer?
While I realize that online video is still a nascent industry and that, as Yogi Berra said, it's difficult to make predictions, especially about the future, two sources last week seemed to point in exactly opposite directions, much like the Scarecrow in the Wizard of Oz.
The New York Times, on Sunday, July 5, claims that videos on the web are getting longer, lasting beyond the 2-3 minute limitations that producers thought were imposed by the outer reaches of their audience's attention spans: "TV networks get much of the credit for the longer-length viewing behavior ... making users accustomed to watching TV online for 20-plus minutes at a time."
By contrast, a recent survey by Frank N. Magid Associates indicates that viewers are moving away from TV broadcasts that are shown online, and that, in the words of MediaPost, "shorter online video -- done professionally -- has been found to be more entertaining than full-length TV shows on traditional TV sets among 37% of consumers."
To try to reconcile these two viewpoints, it would seem that TV viewing online is conditioning users to longer-form programming than previously, and that online video producers are taking advantage of this trend by lengthening their narratives as they increasing compete with TV programming for eyeballs. Thoughts?
The New York Times, on Sunday, July 5, claims that videos on the web are getting longer, lasting beyond the 2-3 minute limitations that producers thought were imposed by the outer reaches of their audience's attention spans: "TV networks get much of the credit for the longer-length viewing behavior ... making users accustomed to watching TV online for 20-plus minutes at a time."
By contrast, a recent survey by Frank N. Magid Associates indicates that viewers are moving away from TV broadcasts that are shown online, and that, in the words of MediaPost, "shorter online video -- done professionally -- has been found to be more entertaining than full-length TV shows on traditional TV sets among 37% of consumers."
To try to reconcile these two viewpoints, it would seem that TV viewing online is conditioning users to longer-form programming than previously, and that online video producers are taking advantage of this trend by lengthening their narratives as they increasing compete with TV programming for eyeballs. Thoughts?
Labels:
online video,
TV
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)